Relax folks: Fr. Robert Barron has it all figured out

Fr. Robert BarronThere’s no need to get all worked up over this “gay marriage” thing. Fr. Robert Barron has it all figured out: “We’ve been here before.”

According to Fr. Barron, writing in an article recently published on the Word on Fire blog, Roman Pontiffs like Pius VI, Pius VII, and Gregory VII all had their run-ins with rogue States and assorted godless rulers.

Indeed, he reminds us, the Catholic Church has been opposed in some form or fashion in every age, and hey, we’re still kicking!

Fr. Barron does concede, however, that this historical perspective may be lost on those of us living in the United States for good reason:

One reason that this [recent Supreme Court ruling] has been rather shocking to American Catholics is that we have had, at least for the last century or so, a fairly benign relationship with the environing culture. Until around 1970, there was, throughout the society and across religious boundaries, a broad moral consensus in our country, especially in regard to sexual and family matters. This is one reason why, in the 1950’s, Archbishop Fulton Sheen could find such a wide and appreciative audience among Protestants and Jews, even as he laid out fundamentally Catholic perspectives on morality. But now that consensus has largely been shattered, and the Church finds itself opposed…

Please allow me to shift the focus back to where it belongs in this matter; namely, away from the culture at large and back on Christ the King and His Holy Catholic Church.

It is true, as Fr. Barron suggests, that the moral fiber of America’s citizens prior to the 196o’s was much stronger than it is today.

So what changed?

As Fr. Barron sees it, the “environing culture” changed, and it did so in such way as to render what was once the “broad moral consensus in regard to sexual and family matters,” little more than a minority opinion.

All of this is true enough, but the question that Fr. Barron and other neo-conservative Catholic commentators don’t dare to ask is this; what exactly facilitated that change?

The answer, of course, is Vatican Council II, but let’s not get ahead of ourselves.

Though they may not have the self-awareness to articulate it in such terms, the view that is held by the Fr. Barrons of the world is such that the culture is considered the protagonist that autonomously determines the Church’s lot in any given age.

Fr. Barron makes this rather clear when he says, “We [Catholics] have had, at least for the last century or so, a fairly benign relationship with the environing culture … but now that consensus has largely been shattered, and the Church finds itself opposed.”

It appears obvious that Fr. Barron is resigned to the notion that the culture will do what the culture will do, and as the ebb and flow of history would have it, the culture in which we currently live (i.e., the preponderance of “We the People”) has chosen to abandon previously accepted moral principles.

This is a fundamentally American mindset wherein it is simply a given that the majority rules.

In this scenario, the Church is then left with no other choice than to carry on in the face of the culture’s whims; presumably in the hope that it will one day, for God only knows what reason, choose to re-embrace, just as inexplicably, the moral precepts that it currently holds in contempt.

This is what leads Fr. Barron to conclude his article saying:

So what do we do? We continue to put forth our point of view winsomely, invitingly, and non-violently, loving our opponents and reaching out to those with whom we disagree. As St. John Paul II said, the Church always proposes, never imposes. And we take a deep breath, preparing for what could be some aggression from the secular society, but we take courage from a great cloud of witnesses who have gone before us. The Church has faced this sort of thing before—and we’re still standing.

While countless well-meaning victims of the post-conciliar crisis are busily applauding Fr. Barron’s article as a moment of much needed perspective; for those of us who, by the grace of God alone, still possess sensus Catholicus, the deficiencies contained in Fr. Barron’s conclusions are rather obvious.

First of all, the Church was not established to put forth “points of view,” winsomely or otherwise; rather, she was commissioned by Our Lord, He to whom “all authority in Heaven and on Earth has been given,” to baptize the nations, teaching them everything whatsoever that He commanded.

In other words, the Church was given the Divine Commission to go forth, on the authority of the King, to Christianize every culture in every nation of the world.

Secondly, the saying attributed to Pope John Paul II above is not even worthy of being called a half-truth; it is more appropriately considered an outright falsehood.

While it is true that the Church does not impose in the sense of forcing individuals to believe that which must be freely accepted in faith, she most certainly does insist on the truths that have been entrusted to her.

As such, it simply isn’t the case that the Church “always proposes,” any more than a responsible parent would simply “propose” to their teen aged child that heroine is dangerous.

It is precisely because our churchmen of the last fifty-plus years have abandoned their mission to baptize and to teach the nations with authority; choosing instead to present Catholic doctrine as if it is little more than an “invitation” worthy of consideration, that the “environing culture” has managed to change so drastically in so short a time.

Prior to the Council, the popes, and the bishops in union with him, did not shy away from making it known that the immutable truths that come to mankind through the Holy Catholic Church are truly nothing less than the Royal Commandments of Christ the King; He who reigns over individuals, societies and States, Catholic or otherwise.

It was in this environment, even in a nation the affairs of which are ordered on a Constitution that extends no more rights to Jesus Christ than to the Dalai Lama, that “Archbishop Fulton Sheen could find such a wide and appreciative audience” even among non-Christians.

Back then, it was widely known by Catholics and non-Catholics alike that the pluralistic U.S. Constitutional model of religious freedom just described is irreconcilable with the Church’s understanding of her mission and the rights of her Divine Founder; her steady confidence in her singular identity, even in the face of every threat, made it plain.

The current environment, by contrast, is one in which our very own churchmen, under the influence of Dignitatis Humanae, the Second Vatican Council’s Declaration on Religious Freedom, wouldn’t dare to assert any special rights or privileges as belonging exclusively to Jesus Christ, much less His Holy Catholic Church.

For example, Bishop William E. Lori, Chairman of the USCCB Ad Hoc Committee on Religious Liberty, when questioned by a reporter said:

When we speak about religious freedom as the first of the freedoms, it’s not to aggrandize the Church, but to uphold the first line of defense for the dignity of the human person.

Oh yes, God forbid our churchmen should behave as if Jesus Christ really is the King of kings, His teachings non-negotiable, and His Church “eminently independent and above all others” (cf Pope Leo XIII, Officio Sanctissimo).

At this, the lesson should be coming into sharper focus: The old maxim is entirely true; as goes the Church, so goes the world.

In other words, the Church is the ultimate protagonist in the relationship between herself and the broader culture; not the other way around as the Fr. Barrons of the world would have it.

With this in mind, one understands that it is not so much the case that previously accepted moral principles have been rejected by a culture that, for no apparent reason, just so happened to go astray. Rather, it is most certainly the case that the leaders of the Church over the last half-century have failed in their obligation to form the culture in the ways of Christ according to the mission that He gave to them.

They did this, in part, by leaving the fundamentally important truth that the Holy Catholic Church teaches with the authority of Almighty God, in the Person of Christ the King, practically unspoken.

In the process, those ordained to speak in His name set the stage for what we are experiencing at this very moment.

You see, the culture at large, comprised as it is of individuals wounded by original sin, saddled with concupiscence, and ever in desperate need of the guidance of a Holy Mother who is not afraid to insist, was left all but orphaned, and so it easily fell prey to wiles of the Evil One who led many to mistake license for liberty and to embrace sin in the name of mercy.

This is how the United States, and the world, so quickly descended into the moral depravity that was enshrined into law in the United States by the Supreme Court’s ruling in Obergefell v Hodges.

The solution to this terrible state of affairs is simple:

Our churchmen need to recover, and in short order, the wherewithal to proclaim the Social Kingship of Our Lord Jesus Christ once more and return to the mission of Christianizing the entire world.

Share this post on:facebooktwittergoogle_plusreddit
Follow us on:facebooktwittergoogle_plusvimeo

Latest Comments

  1. TWN July 2, 2015
  2. my2cents July 2, 2015
  3. John Madison July 2, 2015
  4. Ever mindful July 2, 2015
  5. Peter Lamb July 2, 2015
  6. Barbara July 2, 2015
  7. johnjobilbee July 2, 2015
  8. Lynda July 2, 2015
  9. Lynda July 2, 2015
  10. AlphonsusJr July 2, 2015
  11. AlphonsusJr July 2, 2015
  12. ock July 2, 2015
  13. johnjobilbee July 2, 2015
  14. sank July 2, 2015
  15. Lynda July 2, 2015
  16. Lynda July 2, 2015
  17. johnjobilbee July 2, 2015
  18. JamesTheLesser July 2, 2015
  19. rich July 2, 2015
  20. Ever mindful July 3, 2015
  21. john6 July 3, 2015
  22. In Hoc Signo Vinces July 3, 2015
  23. In Hoc Signo Vinces July 3, 2015
  24. salvemur July 3, 2015
  25. salvemur July 3, 2015
  26. salvemur July 3, 2015
  27. Barbara July 3, 2015
  28. Barbara July 3, 2015
  29. Barbara July 3, 2015
  30. Barbara July 3, 2015
  31. Peter Lamb July 3, 2015
  32. Peter Lamb July 3, 2015
  33. Johnno July 3, 2015
  34. Alarico July 3, 2015
  35. Ever mindful July 3, 2015
  36. mpoulin July 3, 2015
  37. jacobum July 3, 2015
  38. mpoulin July 3, 2015
  39. jacobum July 3, 2015
  40. jacobum July 3, 2015
  41. Alarico July 3, 2015
  42. In Hoc Signo Vinces July 3, 2015
  43. Barbara July 3, 2015
  44. Barbara July 3, 2015
  45. rich July 3, 2015
  46. Barbara July 3, 2015
  47. Barbara July 3, 2015
  48. Barbara July 3, 2015
  49. Indignus famulus July 3, 2015
  50. john6 July 4, 2015
  51. Ever mindful July 4, 2015
  52. salvemur July 4, 2015
  53. salvemur July 4, 2015
  54. Peter Lamb July 4, 2015
  55. Peter Lamb July 4, 2015
  56. de Maria numquam satis July 4, 2015
  57. In Hoc Signo Vinces July 4, 2015
  58. In Hoc Signo Vinces July 4, 2015
  59. In Hoc Signo Vinces July 4, 2015
  60. Peter Lamb July 4, 2015
  61. salvemur July 4, 2015
  62. salvemur July 4, 2015
  63. Peter Lamb July 4, 2015
  64. Peter Lamb July 4, 2015
  65. Barbara July 4, 2015
  66. de Maria numquam satis July 4, 2015
  67. Peter Lamb July 4, 2015
  68. Mike July 4, 2015
  69. Ever mindful July 4, 2015
  70. Indignus famulus July 4, 2015
  71. Indignus famulus July 4, 2015
  72. Lynda July 4, 2015
  73. johnjobilbee July 4, 2015
  74. johnjobilbee July 4, 2015
  75. johnjobilbee July 4, 2015
  76. johnjobilbee July 4, 2015
  77. salvemur July 5, 2015
  78. salvemur July 5, 2015
  79. In Hoc Signo Vinces July 5, 2015
  80. In Hoc Signo Vinces July 5, 2015
  81. In Hoc Signo Vinces July 5, 2015
  82. In Hoc Signo Vinces July 5, 2015
  83. Ever mindful July 5, 2015
  84. Peter Lamb July 5, 2015
  85. Peter Lamb July 5, 2015
  86. salvemur July 5, 2015
  87. Peter Lamb July 5, 2015
  88. salvemur July 5, 2015
  89. salvemur July 5, 2015
  90. Peter Lamb July 5, 2015
  91. Peter Lamb July 5, 2015
  92. salvemur July 5, 2015
  93. Peter Lamb July 5, 2015
  94. salvemur July 5, 2015
  95. In Hoc Signo Vinces July 5, 2015
  96. Ever mindful July 5, 2015
  97. Lynda July 5, 2015
  98. In Hoc Signo Vinces July 5, 2015
  99. In Hoc Signo Vinces July 5, 2015
  100. Indignus famulus July 5, 2015
  101. Peter Lamb July 5, 2015
  102. Peter Lamb July 5, 2015
  103. Ever mindful July 5, 2015
  104. Ever mindful July 5, 2015
  105. Barbara July 5, 2015
  106. Barbara July 5, 2015
  107. Indignus famulus July 5, 2015
  108. Indignus famulus July 5, 2015
  109. Lynda July 5, 2015
  110. Lynda July 5, 2015
  111. Peter Lamb July 6, 2015
  112. my2cents July 6, 2015
  113. In Hoc Signo Vinces July 6, 2015
  114. Alarico July 6, 2015
  115. salvemur July 6, 2015
  116. salvemur July 6, 2015
  117. Indignus famulus July 6, 2015
  118. Indignus famulus July 6, 2015
  119. Indignus famulus July 6, 2015
  120. Peter Lamb July 6, 2015
  121. Indignus famulus July 6, 2015
  122. Indignus famulus July 6, 2015
  123. Lynda July 6, 2015
  124. Indignus famulus July 6, 2015
  125. Indignus famulus July 6, 2015
  126. Peter Lamb July 6, 2015
  127. Indignus famulus July 6, 2015
  128. Peter Lamb July 6, 2015
  129. TWN July 6, 2015
  130. Indignus famulus July 6, 2015
  131. Alarico July 6, 2015
  132. Peter Lamb July 6, 2015
  133. Indignus famulus July 6, 2015
  134. In Hoc Signo Vinces July 6, 2015
  135. Barbara July 6, 2015
  136. Barbara July 6, 2015
  137. Ever mindful July 6, 2015
  138. Indignus famulus July 6, 2015
  139. Quito11 July 7, 2015
  140. Ever mindful July 7, 2015
  141. salvemur July 7, 2015
  142. salvemur July 7, 2015
  143. RoJtM July 7, 2015
  144. salvemur July 7, 2015
  145. Indignus famulus July 7, 2015
  146. Indignus famulus July 7, 2015
  147. In Hoc Signo Vinces July 7, 2015
  148. In Hoc Signo Vinces July 7, 2015
  149. In Hoc Signo Vinces July 7, 2015
  150. In Hoc Signo Vinces July 7, 2015
  151. Indignus famulus July 7, 2015
  152. In Hoc Signo Vinces July 7, 2015
  153. Indignus famulus July 7, 2015
  154. Indignus famulus July 7, 2015
  155. Peter Lamb July 7, 2015
  156. Peter Lamb July 7, 2015
  157. Lynda July 7, 2015
  158. Peter Lamb July 7, 2015
  159. Ever mindful July 7, 2015
  160. Ever mindful July 7, 2015
  161. In Hoc Signo Vinces July 7, 2015
  162. In Hoc Signo Vinces July 7, 2015
  163. salvemur July 8, 2015
  164. Peter Lamb July 8, 2015
  165. Peter Lamb July 8, 2015
  166. salvemur July 8, 2015
  167. salvemur July 8, 2015
  168. salvemur July 8, 2015
  169. In Hoc Signo Vinces July 8, 2015
  170. salvemur July 8, 2015
  171. salvemur July 8, 2015
  172. de Maria numquam satis July 8, 2015
  173. Indignus famulus July 8, 2015
  174. Indignus famulus July 8, 2015
  175. Indignus famulus July 8, 2015
  176. Peter Lamb July 8, 2015
  177. Indignus famulus July 8, 2015
  178. salvemur July 9, 2015
  179. salvemur July 9, 2015
  180. In Hoc Signo Vinces July 9, 2015
  181. Indignus famulus July 9, 2015