Is Francis a heretic?

francis-anathemaI know… Many of you have already blurted the answer out loud. Even so, humor me and keep reading.

In the aftermath of Francis’ unambiguous clarification that Amoris Laetitia is an invitation to Holy Communion for those who obstinately persist in mortal sin, the neo-Catholic world has gone into full meltdown mode.

In at least one noteworthy case, namely, that of Robert Royal, it would appear that the scales may be falling from some eyes. In others, not so much.

Jeff Mirus at Catholic Culture, for instance, penned a defense of His Humbleness under the oh-so-lengthy-why-bother-to-read-any-further title, Not heretical: Pope Francis’ approval of the Argentine bishops’ policy on invalid marriages. (I read it in its entirety anyway so you don’t have to torture yourself, but feel free.)

Mirus states:

… some Catholics are now saying that Pope Francis has crossed the line from doctrinal fuzziness to material heresy. But this is not at all the case.

It is not incompatible with the Church’s doctrinal teaching on either marriage or Communion to argue that, under some circumstances, persons involved in invalid marriages ought to be admitted to Communion.

Actually,  some Catholics… you know… the ones whose heads haven’t been buried shoulders deep in the sand, have been saying that Francis crossed the line a very long time ago and for very good reason.

Be that as it may, let’s be very clear about the “persons” Francis and Mirus are discussing:

We are talking about persons who obstinately persist in a relationship characterized by the grave sin of adultery.

In his attempt to defend Francis, Mirus contends that the Church has always said that such persons “ought to be admitted to Communion under some circumstances.”

Canon Lawyer Edward Peters provided partial support for Mirus’ contention (we’ll get to his criticisms of Mirus later) saying:

As holy Communion may be (and perhaps even should be, assuming sorrow for sin, CCC 1393) taken by one in venial sin, Mirus argues that some divorced-and-remarried Catholics should feel free to approach for holy Communion. Now, everything Mirus says so far is at least arguably, and much of it is actually, true.

Really?

What part of Adultery = Mortal Sin do these people fail to understand?

Remember, the Beunos Aires bishops’ directive of which Francis said, “There are no other interpretations” provides the following scenario as an example of one wherein the invitation to Communion is possible:

An invalid “second marriage” (civil) wherein at least one party remains validly married to another person. An annulment isn’t “feasible,” and one or both parties refuse to live in continence.

Sure sounds like the mortal sin of adultery to me.

Ed Peters goes on to say in his qualified defense of Jeff Mirus:

“One’s approaching for holy Communion is a matter of personal conscience chiefly guided by Canon 916.” [Emphasis in original.]

OK, I’ll bite. What does Canon 916 say?

Can. 916: Anyone who is conscious of grave sin may not celebrate Mass or receive the Body of the Lord without previously having been to sacramental confession, unless there is a grave reason and there is no opportunity to confess; in this case the person is to remember the obligation to make an act of perfect contrition, which includes the resolve to go to confession as soon as possible. 

Even if one allows that a “grave reason” exists in the case under discussion (we’ll take a closer look at this momentarily)  what follows in Canon 916 is crucial: and there is no opportunity to confess.

The canon even makes clear that the obligation to confess, with perfect contrition, remains; all of which implies that the would-be recipient of Communion in this case has a firm purpose of amendment to cease committing adultery.

This doesn’t even come close to describing the hypothetical scenario provided by the Argentine bishops and endorsed by Francis!

Mirus, however, thinks he found a loophole that exonerates all concerned.

In order for a sin to be mortal, he reminds us, three things are required.

Let’s review these requirements, and more importantly, let’s see if they apply to the scenario described in the Beunos Aires directive:

  1. Grave matter. CHECK.
  2. Full knowledge. CHECK [“A subject may know full well the rule, yet…” (cf AL 301)]
  3. Deliberate consent. Not so fast, says Jeff!

Mirus, not to be deterred, provided his own make believe scenario by engaging in what is readily recognized as an exercise in good ol’ fashioned situation ethics. He writes:

Very briefly, then, I would argue that the following is the most likely scenario in which the presumption that only venial sin is involved may be reasonably justified:

  1. An invalidly married couple has had children together, who are still at home.
  2. Either the man or the woman recognizes the sinfulness of the “marriage”, regrets having entered into it, and desires now to do what is right (which in this case would be for the parents to live as brother and sister while still caring for their children as mother and father in the same household).
  3. The other party refuses to live as brother and sister.
  4. The other party says he (or she) will leave the family if sexual relations are refused.
  5. Hence the man or woman in question continues sexual relations, in effect under duress, to ensure that his or her children are not deprived of one parent.

Yes, God forbid the children be deprived of a father who uses his presence in the family home as a bargaining chip in order to extort sex from their mother!

According to the “likely scenario” provided by Mirus, the so-called “reasonable justification” for downgrading adultery to a venial sin thereby opening the way to Holy Communion ceases to be valid once the kids grow up.

I can just see it now…

Suzy: Jim, I have some bad news for you. Our youngest is turning 18 tomorrow. I am cutting you off at the stroke of midnight… no pun intended.

This is the kind of absurdity that arises when one attempts to make excuses for the inexcusable rather than simply upholding objective truth.

I have an idea… How about we add a sixth item to Mirus’ list; one that apparently never crossed his mind – a Catholic one that Francis would shudder to even imagine:

6. During the much ballyhooed “process of accompaniment” with his or her pastor, the persons having sex outside of marriage are made aware that means do not justify ends; i.e., a good intention does not render an objectively evil act good, therefore, the obligation to desist from the mortal sin remains, and until such time as their lives are so amended the sacraments may not be approached.

As it is, Mirus’ “likely scenario” is reminiscent of a similar attempt to defend Francis after he publicly endorsed the use of “oral contraception” and “condoms” in light of the Zika virus scare.

Readers may recall that Fr. Robert Gahl, an Associate Professor of moral philosophy at the Pontifical University of the Holy Cross, said that Francis must have had in mind, get this:

“…extreme scenarios in which, for instance, a woman is threatened by a violent, Zika-infected husband to have sexual intercourse with her.”

What the Hell is it with these people?

What Mirus and Gahl have in common is that they are far more comfortable with convoluted scenarios wherein women are forced to engage in sex against their will than they are with admitting the plain truth about Francis.

Ed Peters, to his credit, does correct Mirus on two important points:

First, he points out that Canon 915 requires the Minister of Holy Communion not to admit those who obstinately persist in manifest grave sin; irrespective of the would-be recipient’s personal “conscience.”

Secondly, Mirus argues:

I have repeatedly made the point that the rules governing reception of Communion are disciplinary, not doctrinal.

Let’s stop here for a moment. Notice that Mirus is unashamed, perhaps even proud, of having made this idiotic assertion repeatedly; as if the disciplines governing the reception of Holy Communion are not inextricably linked to the immutable doctrines from which they arise. We’ll come back to this…

Mirus continues:

It is impossible to prove that advocacy of any disciplinary approach indicates heresy in the mind of the advocate.

Peters isn’t buying it, writing:

That is not correct. A classic example pointed to a man whose refusal to abide by disciplinary norms such as genuflecting before the tabernacle might show a wordless, but clearly heretical, denial of the Real Presence.

NOTE: I wonder if Peters has anyone in particular in mind here… say, a certain Argentinian in white who has no trouble dropping to his knees when the Humblecam is rolling but never manages to do so before the Most Holy Eucharist?

Mirus writes as if “the mind of the advocate” in this matter is a mystery.

Please, the mind of Francis has never been a mystery. He has been dumping its poisonous contents on everyone within earshot for more than three years now.  We have been calling him to account for his heterodoxy on these pages since March 2013!

In the present case, “the mind of the advocate” is spelled out with remarkable clarity in the pages of Amoris Laetitia, of which Francis owns every last condemnable word.

This brings me back to the inextricable link that exists between doctrine and discipline.

Just as the venerable discipline of the Church is a direct outgrowth of authentic Catholic doctrine, so too is the sacrilege being promoted by Francis the outgrowth of the false doctrine set forth in Amoris Laetitia!

Long story short, folks, there is no mystery here:

Jorge Mario Bergoglio, alias Francis, is a blasphemous heretic who with every passing day is inching ever closer to proving his pertinacity beyond any reasonable doubt.

aka Under Attack

Share this post on:facebooktwittergoogle_plusreddit
Follow us on:facebooktwittergoogle_plusvimeo

Latest Comments

  1. Cortez September 16, 2016
  2. Mike September 16, 2016
  3. Cortez September 16, 2016
    • Theresa September 16, 2016
      • Cortez September 16, 2016
        • helpusLord September 16, 2016
    • helpusLord September 16, 2016
      • Cortez September 16, 2016
    • The Papal Subject September 16, 2016
  4. Ana Milan September 16, 2016
  5. helpusLord September 16, 2016
  6. Lynda September 16, 2016
  7. helpusLord September 16, 2016
    • helpusLord September 16, 2016
  8. OldTradCat September 16, 2016
  9. mpoulin September 16, 2016
  10. John Coltrane September 16, 2016
    • Lynda September 17, 2016
  11. John Coltrane September 16, 2016
  12. John Coltrane September 16, 2016
    • MMC September 16, 2016
      • John Coltrane September 16, 2016
        • Catherine September 17, 2016
        • Filumene September 17, 2016
        • Filumene September 17, 2016
        • MMC September 18, 2016
          • John Coltrane September 19, 2016
      • John Coltrane September 16, 2016
    • Mike September 16, 2016
      • helpusLord September 16, 2016
    • Catherine September 16, 2016
    • Paul van Dongen September 17, 2016
    • CraigV September 17, 2016
  13. helpusLord September 16, 2016
    • John Coltrane September 16, 2016
      • Catherine September 16, 2016
        • John Coltrane September 17, 2016
          • helpusLord September 17, 2016
          • helpusLord September 17, 2016
          • John Coltrane September 17, 2016
          • helpusLord September 17, 2016
          • John Coltrane September 17, 2016
          • Catherine September 17, 2016
          • Catherine September 17, 2016
      • helpusLord September 16, 2016
    • John Coltrane September 17, 2016
      • helpusLord September 17, 2016
        • helpusLord September 17, 2016
        • John Coltrane September 17, 2016
          • helpusLord September 17, 2016
          • John Coltrane September 17, 2016
      • Catherine September 17, 2016
  14. The Papal Subject September 16, 2016
  15. The Papal Subject September 16, 2016
  16. helpusLord September 16, 2016
    • helpusLord September 16, 2016
      • rich September 16, 2016
        • rich September 16, 2016
          • helpusLord September 16, 2016
          • Rushintuit September 17, 2016
    • John Coltrane September 16, 2016
      • John Coltrane September 16, 2016
        • mpoulin September 18, 2016
      • Catherine September 17, 2016
    • John Coltrane September 16, 2016
  17. rich September 16, 2016
    • helpusLord September 16, 2016
    • John Coltrane September 16, 2016
      • rich September 17, 2016
        • John Coltrane September 17, 2016
        • John Coltrane September 17, 2016
          • Catherine September 17, 2016
        • ock September 17, 2016
      • Mike September 17, 2016
      • Catherine September 17, 2016
      • Catherine September 17, 2016
  18. ock September 16, 2016
    • ock September 16, 2016
    • John Coltrane September 16, 2016
      • John Coltrane September 16, 2016
      • ock September 17, 2016
        • ock September 17, 2016
          • ock September 17, 2016
        • ock September 17, 2016
        • John Coltrane September 17, 2016
          • Servant of Our Lady September 17, 2016
          • John Coltrane September 17, 2016
          • John Coltrane September 17, 2016
          • Servant of Our Lady September 17, 2016
          • John Coltrane September 17, 2016
          • John Coltrane September 17, 2016
          • prisca ann September 18, 2016
        • Rushintuit September 17, 2016
          • Servant of Our Lady September 17, 2016
          • John Coltrane September 19, 2016
  19. ock September 16, 2016
  20. helpusLord September 17, 2016
    • John Coltrane September 17, 2016
      • ock September 17, 2016
        • John Coltrane September 19, 2016
          • Ursula September 20, 2016
  21. helpusLord September 17, 2016
    • John Coltrane September 17, 2016
      • John Coltrane September 17, 2016
        • helpusLord September 17, 2016
          • John Coltrane September 17, 2016
          • helpusLord September 17, 2016
          • John Coltrane September 17, 2016
          • helpusLord September 17, 2016
          • John Coltrane September 17, 2016
          • helpusLord September 17, 2016
          • John Coltrane September 17, 2016
          • helpusLord September 18, 2016
  22. Danielpan September 17, 2016
    • helpusLord September 17, 2016
  23. helpusLord September 17, 2016
    • John Coltrane September 17, 2016
      • helpusLord September 17, 2016
        • John Coltrane September 17, 2016
          • helpusLord September 17, 2016
          • John Coltrane September 17, 2016
          • John Coltrane September 17, 2016
    • John Coltrane September 17, 2016
      • helpusLord September 17, 2016
        • John Coltrane September 17, 2016
          • helpusLord September 17, 2016
          • helpusLord September 17, 2016
          • John Coltrane September 17, 2016
        • John Coltrane September 17, 2016
          • helpusLord September 17, 2016
          • helpusLord September 17, 2016
          • helpusLord September 17, 2016
          • John Coltrane September 17, 2016
          • helpusLord September 17, 2016
          • Catherine September 18, 2016
      • helpusLord September 21, 2016
  24. helpusLord September 17, 2016
  25. Ever mindful September 17, 2016
  26. Cortez September 17, 2016
    • ock September 17, 2016
  27. Catherine September 17, 2016
  28. Rushintuit September 17, 2016
  29. maryiloveher September 17, 2016
    • Rushintuit September 17, 2016
      • Catherine September 18, 2016
  30. maryiloveher September 17, 2016
    • maryiloveher September 17, 2016
      • maryiloveher September 17, 2016
      • ock September 17, 2016
  31. maryiloveher September 17, 2016
  32. ock September 17, 2016
  33. Rushintuit September 17, 2016
  34. maryiloveher September 17, 2016
  35. johnjobilbee September 17, 2016
  36. johnjobilbee September 17, 2016
  37. johnjobilbee September 17, 2016
    • Servant of Our Lady September 17, 2016
  38. my2cents September 17, 2016
    • Lynda September 17, 2016
      • my2cents September 17, 2016
        • Catherine September 17, 2016
  39. CraigV September 17, 2016
    • Servant of Our Lady September 17, 2016
  40. helpusLord September 17, 2016
    • helpusLord September 17, 2016
      • Catherine September 18, 2016
        • helpusLord September 18, 2016
          • helpusLord September 18, 2016
  41. helpusLord September 17, 2016
    • helpusLord September 17, 2016
  42. mpoulin September 18, 2016
    • mpoulin September 18, 2016
      • John Coltrane September 18, 2016
    • John Coltrane September 18, 2016
  43. crawler September 18, 2016
    • helpusLord September 18, 2016
  44. helpusLord September 18, 2016
    • helpusLord September 18, 2016
  45. John Coltrane September 18, 2016
    • Mike September 19, 2016
      • John Coltrane September 19, 2016
        • Mike September 19, 2016
          • John Coltrane September 19, 2016
  46. John Coltrane September 18, 2016
    • Mike September 18, 2016
      • John Coltrane September 18, 2016
      • Mike September 18, 2016
        • John Coltrane September 18, 2016
        • John Coltrane September 18, 2016
          • MMC September 19, 2016
          • John Coltrane September 19, 2016
  47. mpoulin September 18, 2016
    • John Coltrane September 18, 2016
      • mpoulin September 18, 2016
        • John Coltrane September 19, 2016
          • John Coltrane September 19, 2016
  48. helpusLord September 19, 2016
    • helpusLord September 19, 2016
      • Ever mindful September 19, 2016
    • John Coltrane September 19, 2016
      • Ursula September 20, 2016
        • John Coltrane September 20, 2016
    • helpusLord September 23, 2016
      • helpusLord September 23, 2016
    • helpusLord September 23, 2016
  49. Lynda September 19, 2016
  50. MMC September 19, 2016
    • John Coltrane September 19, 2016
      • Ursula September 20, 2016
        • John Coltrane September 20, 2016
          • Ursula September 20, 2016
    • John Coltrane September 19, 2016
      • Ursula September 20, 2016
        • John Coltrane September 20, 2016
          • Ursula September 20, 2016
          • John Coltrane September 20, 2016
          • St Cyprian September 21, 2016
          • John Coltrane September 21, 2016
  51. Caimbeul September 20, 2016
    • John Coltrane September 20, 2016
      • Ursula September 20, 2016
      • Rushintuit September 20, 2016
        • John Coltrane September 20, 2016
  52. Caimbeul September 20, 2016
    • John Coltrane September 20, 2016
      • Caimbeul September 20, 2016
        • John Coltrane September 20, 2016
      • Rushintuit September 20, 2016
        • John Coltrane September 20, 2016
          • Ursula September 20, 2016
          • John Coltrane September 20, 2016
          • Ursula September 20, 2016
          • Rushintuit September 20, 2016
          • John Coltrane September 20, 2016
          • John Coltrane September 20, 2016
          • Mike September 20, 2016
  53. Caimbeul September 20, 2016
    • John Coltrane September 20, 2016
      • Caimbeul September 20, 2016
        • John Coltrane September 20, 2016
          • Caimbeul September 20, 2016
          • John Coltrane September 20, 2016
        • John Coltrane September 20, 2016
      • Ursula September 20, 2016
        • Caimbeul September 20, 2016
        • John Coltrane September 20, 2016
          • Ursula September 20, 2016
          • John Coltrane September 20, 2016
          • John Coltrane September 20, 2016
  54. Rushintuit September 20, 2016
    • John Coltrane September 20, 2016
      • Caimbeul September 20, 2016
        • John Coltrane September 20, 2016
  55. Caimbeul September 20, 2016
    • John Coltrane September 20, 2016
      • Caimbeul September 20, 2016
        • John Coltrane September 20, 2016
          • Caimbeul September 20, 2016
          • John Coltrane September 20, 2016
          • Caimbeul September 20, 2016
          • Caimbeul September 20, 2016
          • John Coltrane September 20, 2016
  56. Rushintuit September 20, 2016
    • John Coltrane September 20, 2016
      • johnjobilbee September 20, 2016
        • John Coltrane September 20, 2016
          • johnjobilbee September 20, 2016
  57. johnjobilbee September 20, 2016
    • John Coltrane September 20, 2016
      • johnjobilbee September 20, 2016
        • John Coltrane September 20, 2016
          • johnjobilbee September 20, 2016
          • John Coltrane September 21, 2016
          • John Coltrane September 21, 2016
  58. johnjobilbee September 20, 2016
    • John Coltrane September 20, 2016
      • johnjobilbee September 20, 2016
      • johnjobilbee September 20, 2016
        • John Coltrane September 21, 2016
  59. helpusLord September 20, 2016
    • helpusLord September 20, 2016
      • John Coltrane September 21, 2016
    • John Coltrane September 21, 2016
  60. Ursula September 21, 2016
    • Ursula September 21, 2016
      • johnjobilbee September 22, 2016
  61. helpusLord September 21, 2016
  62. helpusLord September 21, 2016
  63. helpusLord September 21, 2016
  64. helpusLord September 22, 2016
    • helpusLord September 22, 2016
  65. Lynda September 24, 2016
  66. helpusLord September 24, 2016

Leave a Reply