Will the new SSPX Superior General strike an old tone?

Fr. Davide PagliaraniOn 11 July 2018, the Priestly Society of St. Pius X (FSSPX) elected a new Superior General – Fr. Davide Pagliarani, until then, the District Superior of Italy.

Based on its public commentary of the past two years or so, it is unfortunately difficult to say what the SSPX considers its greatest challenges in the present day.

I’ve written rather extensively in this space about the mixed and contradictory messages that have been coming from the SSPX in recent years. I won’t repeat those concerns here other than to say that a sincere seeker of truth today may very well come away from their website more confused than ever as to what is, and what is not, consonant tradition.

As of this moment, it seems that the SSPX has lost sight of the grave necessity of having a very clear and consistent public stance on the current state of affairs in the Church; offering bold and unambiguous condemnations of every blasphemy and heresy that comes forth from men in authority who are trusted by many.

Doing so in our day requires, above all, a willingness to address head-on the unprecedented mockery that is being made of the papacy. One thinks back to October of 2013 and Bishop Fellay’s public declaration, which has since faded into a deafening silence, “We have in front of us a genuine Modernist!”

Returning to such clarity and conviction, in my view, is the major task that lies before the SSPX, and only time will tell if the election of a new Superior General will make a difference in this regard.

One thing is certain: To the extent that the SSPX is pleased to operate – as it has appeared of late – under the assumption that it is enough to simply minister to their own, to focus on priestly formation, and to manage their own internal affairs, while taking care not to offend neo-conservative sensibilities, it will ultimately fail to adequately serve the needs of God’s people in the present day.

Writing in the August 2008 issue of Si Si No No, Fr. Pagliarani said of Vatican II:

The very finality of the Council, convoked with the explicit intention not to define truths of faith and not to condemn error (cf. Gaudet Mater Ecclesia), inaugurated a magisterium with a novel method and approach… the Second Vatican Council was convoked not to define dogmas, correct errors, or condemn doctrinal deviations as in the past, but to bond with the modern world. This decision to leave aside any intention of imposing certain truths of faith meant that the Council was intended to abstain from teaching in the objective, traditional, and magisterial sense of the term.

These words were written nearly a decade ago and one wonders:

Does Fr. Pagliarani believe that the Society has a duty to teach in the objective, traditional, and magisterial sense of the term, and if so, does he still believe that this necessarily involves correcting errors and condemning doctrinal deviations, otherwise it will merely be bonding with the modern world?

We shall see. In the meantime, let us pray and fast for the SSPX and for Fr. Pagliarani, as clearly he has a lot of important work to do.

AKA No Voice 2

Share this post on:facebooktwittergoogle_plusreddit
Follow us on:facebooktwittergoogle_plusvimeo

Latest Comments

  1. ConcernedCommenter July 12, 2018
      • kellyann July 15, 2018
    • Tom A July 12, 2018
      • The Great Stalin July 12, 2018
        • Tom A July 12, 2018
        • 2Vermont July 12, 2018
          • ConcernedCommenter July 12, 2018
          • Tom A July 12, 2018
          • Tom A July 12, 2018
          • The Great Stalin July 14, 2018
          • Tom A July 14, 2018
          • St Cyprian July 15, 2018
      • ConcernedCommenter July 12, 2018
        • Melanie July 12, 2018
          • ConcernedCommenter July 12, 2018
        • Tom A July 12, 2018
          • ConcernedCommenter July 12, 2018
          • sweepoutthefilth July 12, 2018
      • Munda Cor Meum July 12, 2018
        • FromPoland July 12, 2018
          • The Great Stalin July 13, 2018
          • Tom A July 14, 2018
  2. Melanie July 12, 2018
    • Munda Cor Meum July 12, 2018
      • The Papal Subject July 12, 2018
        • St Cyprian July 13, 2018
          • The Papal Subject July 13, 2018
          • Tom A July 13, 2018
          • The Papal Subject July 14, 2018
          • Tom A July 14, 2018
    • Gods servant first July 13, 2018
  3. sweepoutthefilth July 12, 2018
    • Melanie July 12, 2018
      • sweepoutthefilth July 12, 2018
        • Melanie July 12, 2018
        • Melanie July 12, 2018
          • sweepoutthefilth July 12, 2018
          • Gods servant first July 13, 2018
      • Lake Erie July 13, 2018
        • Melanie July 13, 2018
          • R.K.C. July 14, 2018
        • fast ferrari July 14, 2018
    • The Papal Subject July 14, 2018
    • Lynda July 17, 2018
  4. The Great Stalin July 12, 2018
    • The Papal Subject July 12, 2018
      • Gods servant first July 13, 2018
        • rich July 13, 2018
        • The Papal Subject July 13, 2018
          • The Great Stalin July 13, 2018
          • The Papal Subject July 13, 2018
          • The Great Stalin July 13, 2018
          • The Papal Subject July 13, 2018
  5. 2Vermont July 12, 2018
    • LennyB July 12, 2018
      • LennyB July 12, 2018
      • Melanie July 12, 2018
        • LennyB July 12, 2018
          • LennyB July 12, 2018
          • Melanie July 12, 2018
          • LennyB July 12, 2018
  6. Stonka Ziemniaczana July 12, 2018
  7. sweepoutthefilth July 12, 2018
    • sweepoutthefilth July 12, 2018
      • The Great Stalin July 12, 2018
        • sweepoutthefilth July 12, 2018
          • The Great Stalin July 13, 2018
    • Fleur de Lis July 13, 2018
      • sweepoutthefilth July 13, 2018
      • sweepoutthekilts July 14, 2018
  8. Al The Silent Crusader July 12, 2018
    • LennyB July 12, 2018
    • The Papal Subject July 12, 2018
      • rich July 12, 2018
        • The Papal Subject July 12, 2018
          • The Great Stalin July 13, 2018
          • The Papal Subject July 13, 2018
          • Tom A July 14, 2018
          • The Papal Subject July 14, 2018
          • coastalfarm July 14, 2018
          • The Papal Subject July 15, 2018
  9. FromPoland July 12, 2018
    • Stonka Ziemniaczana July 12, 2018
      • rich July 12, 2018
        • FromPoland July 12, 2018
          • rich July 12, 2018
          • rich July 12, 2018
  10. FromPoland July 12, 2018
  11. FromPoland July 12, 2018
    • rich July 12, 2018
      • Tom A July 12, 2018
        • FromPoland July 12, 2018
          • Lynda July 17, 2018
        • rich July 12, 2018
  12. FromPoland July 12, 2018
  13. The Great Stalin July 13, 2018
    • sweepoutthefilth July 13, 2018
      • The Great Stalin July 13, 2018
        • sweepoutthefilth July 13, 2018
          • The Great Stalin July 13, 2018
          • Melanie July 13, 2018
        • The Papal Subject July 13, 2018
          • The Great Stalin July 13, 2018
          • The Papal Subject July 13, 2018
          • The Great Stalin July 13, 2018
          • utahagen July 13, 2018
          • The Papal Subject July 13, 2018
  14. my2cents July 13, 2018
    • sweepoutthefilth July 13, 2018
      • The Great Stalin July 13, 2018
        • The Papal Subject July 13, 2018
          • The Great Stalin July 13, 2018
          • The Papal Subject July 13, 2018
          • The Papal Subject July 13, 2018
          • The Great Stalin July 13, 2018
          • Tom A July 13, 2018
          • 2Vermont July 13, 2018
  15. sweepoutthefilth July 13, 2018
    • sweepoutthefilth July 13, 2018
      • sweepoutthefilth July 13, 2018
        • The Great Stalin July 13, 2018
    • The Great Stalin July 13, 2018
  16. sweepoutthefilth July 13, 2018
  17. The Great Stalin July 13, 2018
    • FromPoland July 13, 2018
      • sweepoutthefilth July 13, 2018
  18. sweepoutthefilth July 13, 2018
    • The Great Stalin July 13, 2018
  19. sweepoutthefilth July 13, 2018
  20. sweepoutthefilth July 13, 2018
    • sweepoutthefilth July 13, 2018
      • sweepoutthefilth July 13, 2018
        • The Great Stalin July 13, 2018
      • The Great Stalin July 13, 2018
        • sweepoutthefilth July 13, 2018
          • The Great Stalin July 13, 2018
        • sweepoutthefilth July 13, 2018
        • sweepoutthefilth July 13, 2018
    • Melanie July 13, 2018
      • sweepoutthefilth July 13, 2018
        • sweepoutthefilth July 13, 2018
          • sweepoutthefilth July 13, 2018
          • Melanie July 13, 2018
        • Lynda July 17, 2018
      • sweepoutthefilth July 13, 2018
      • utahagen July 13, 2018
        • The Great Stalin July 13, 2018
          • utahagen July 13, 2018
        • sweepoutthefilth July 13, 2018
        • rich July 13, 2018
          • The Great Stalin July 14, 2018
        • Lynda July 17, 2018
  21. sweepoutthefilth July 13, 2018
    • Melanie July 13, 2018
      • sweepoutthefilth July 13, 2018
      • sweepoutthefilth July 13, 2018
        • The Great Stalin July 13, 2018
          • MS July 14, 2018
    • Lynda July 17, 2018
  22. The Great Stalin July 13, 2018
    • sweepoutthefilth July 13, 2018
      • The Great Stalin July 13, 2018
      • sweepoutthefilth July 13, 2018
  23. sweepoutthefilth July 13, 2018
    • sweepoutthefilth July 13, 2018
      • MS July 14, 2018
        • MS July 14, 2018
          • The Great Stalin July 14, 2018
          • sweepoutthefilth July 14, 2018
    • The Great Stalin July 13, 2018
    • rich July 13, 2018
      • The Great Stalin July 14, 2018
      • 2Vermont July 14, 2018
        • The Great Stalin July 14, 2018
          • 2Vermont July 14, 2018
        • rich July 14, 2018
        • Fleur de Lis July 14, 2018
          • sweepoutthefilth July 15, 2018
      • The Great Stalin July 14, 2018
        • 2Vermont July 14, 2018
          • The Great Stalin July 14, 2018
          • 2Vermont July 14, 2018
          • Fleur de Lis July 14, 2018
      • The Great Stalin July 14, 2018
        • The Great Stalin July 14, 2018
          • rich July 14, 2018
        • rich July 14, 2018
          • 2Vermont July 14, 2018
        • The Great Stalin July 14, 2018
          • The Great Stalin July 14, 2018
          • rich July 15, 2018
          • 2Vermont July 15, 2018
  24. AlphonsusJr July 14, 2018
    • FromPoland July 14, 2018
  25. Fleur de Lis July 14, 2018
  26. sweepoutthefilth July 14, 2018
    • Melanie July 14, 2018
    • Fleur de Lis July 14, 2018
      • Fleur de Lis July 14, 2018
  27. sweepoutthefilth July 14, 2018
  28. Fleur de Lis July 14, 2018
    • sweepoutthefilth July 14, 2018
      • Fleur de Lis July 14, 2018
        • sweepoutthefilth July 15, 2018
  29. my2cents July 14, 2018
    • sweepoutthefilth July 14, 2018
    • fast ferrari July 14, 2018
      • my2cents July 15, 2018
    • Lynda July 17, 2018
  30. FromPoland July 14, 2018
  31. The Great Stalin July 14, 2018
    • FromPoland July 14, 2018
      • MS July 15, 2018
    • The Papal Subject July 14, 2018
  32. my2cents July 14, 2018
    • sweepoutthefilth July 14, 2018
      • sweepoutthefilth July 14, 2018
        • rich July 15, 2018
  33. FromPoland July 14, 2018
  34. The Great Stalin July 15, 2018
    • The Papal Subject July 15, 2018
      • The Great Stalin July 15, 2018
      • sweepoutthekilts July 16, 2018
    • Melanie July 15, 2018
      • 2Vermont July 16, 2018
        • Melanie July 16, 2018
          • Tom A July 16, 2018
          • 2Vermont July 16, 2018
          • Melanie July 16, 2018
          • 2Vermont July 17, 2018
          • 2Vermont July 17, 2018
          • 2Vermont July 17, 2018
          • Lynda July 17, 2018
  35. sweepoutthefilth July 15, 2018
  36. sweepoutthefilth July 15, 2018
  37. The Great Stalin July 15, 2018
  38. kellyann July 15, 2018
  39. sweepoutthefilth July 15, 2018
    • sweepoutthefilth July 15, 2018
    • The Great Stalin July 15, 2018
      • rich July 16, 2018
        • The Great Stalin July 16, 2018
          • Tom A July 16, 2018
      • The Great Stalin July 16, 2018
        • my2cents July 16, 2018
          • The Great Stalin July 16, 2018
          • 2Vermont July 16, 2018
        • The Great Stalin July 16, 2018
          • my2cents July 16, 2018
          • Melanie July 16, 2018
          • The Great Stalin July 16, 2018
          • Melanie July 16, 2018
          • The Great Stalin July 16, 2018
          • Melanie July 16, 2018
          • The Great Stalin July 16, 2018
          • Melanie July 16, 2018
          • The Great Stalin July 16, 2018
  40. Katherine July 15, 2018
    • The Great Stalin July 16, 2018
  41. The Great Stalin July 16, 2018
    • The Papal Subject July 16, 2018
      • The Great Stalin July 16, 2018
        • my2cents July 16, 2018
          • The Papal Subject July 16, 2018
  42. The Great Stalin July 16, 2018
    • Tom A July 16, 2018
    • St Cyprian July 16, 2018
      • St Cyprian July 16, 2018
  43. The Great Stalin July 16, 2018
    • sweepoutthefilth July 16, 2018
      • sweepoutthekilts July 16, 2018
        • The Great Stalin July 16, 2018
          • Tom A July 16, 2018
          • sweepoutthekilts July 16, 2018
          • Tom A July 16, 2018
        • St Cyprian July 16, 2018
        • sweepoutthefilth July 16, 2018
          • sweepoutthefilth July 16, 2018
          • sweepoutthekilts July 16, 2018
          • FromPoland July 16, 2018
          • The Great Stalin July 16, 2018
        • 2Vermont July 16, 2018
  44. FromPoland July 16, 2018
    • 2Vermont July 17, 2018
  45. sweepoutthefilth July 16, 2018
  46. sweepoutthekilts July 16, 2018
    • sweepoutthefilth July 16, 2018
  47. sweepoutthefilth July 16, 2018
  48. sweepoutthefilth July 16, 2018
    • FromPoland July 16, 2018
      • sweepoutthefilth July 16, 2018
      • sweepoutthekilts July 16, 2018
      • sweepoutthekilts July 16, 2018
  49. sweepoutthefilth July 16, 2018
  50. sweepoutthefilth July 16, 2018
    • FromPoland July 16, 2018
      • sweepoutthefilth July 16, 2018
      • sweepoutthekilts July 16, 2018
  51. sweepoutthefilth July 16, 2018
  52. sweepoutthefilth July 16, 2018
    • sweepoutthekilts July 16, 2018
  53. Tom A July 16, 2018
  54. The Great Stalin July 16, 2018
    • Tom A July 16, 2018
  55. The Great Stalin July 16, 2018
    • Tom A July 17, 2018
      • The Great Stalin July 17, 2018
        • Tom A July 17, 2018
          • The Great Stalin July 17, 2018
          • Tom A July 17, 2018
          • The Great Stalin July 17, 2018
      • sweepoutthefilth July 17, 2018
  56. sweepoutthefilth July 16, 2018
    • sweepoutthekilts July 16, 2018
  57. sweepoutthefilth July 16, 2018
    • sweepoutthekilts July 16, 2018
      • The Great Stalin July 17, 2018
        • sweepoutthefilth July 17, 2018
          • sweepoutthekilts July 17, 2018
          • rich July 17, 2018
  58. rich July 17, 2018
    • Tom A July 17, 2018
    • The Great Stalin July 17, 2018
  59. my2cents July 17, 2018
  60. sweepoutthefilth July 17, 2018
  61. FromPoland July 17, 2018
    • sweepoutthefilth July 17, 2018
      • FromPoland July 17, 2018
        • The Great Stalin July 17, 2018
          • FromPoland July 17, 2018
          • sweepoutthefilth July 17, 2018
        • sweepoutthekilts July 17, 2018
          • sweepoutthefilth July 17, 2018
          • sweepoutthekilts July 17, 2018
          • The Great Stalin July 17, 2018
          • sweepoutthekilts July 17, 2018
          • The Great Stalin July 17, 2018
          • 2Vermont July 17, 2018
  62. sweepoutthefilth July 17, 2018
  63. FromPoland July 17, 2018
  64. Lynda July 17, 2018
    • The Great Stalin July 18, 2018
  65. 2Vermont July 21, 2018
  66. my2cents July 21, 2018
    • 2Vermont July 21, 2018

Leave a Reply