Dear Gabby

Dear GabbyA priest looking for advice on how to advance the Church in a fast-paced world so often embroiled in conflict recently approached a well-placed cleric who had been a religious order priest and bishop for many years.

In response, the bishop answered, in part, by sharing the following true story:

A priest went as a missionary to an area where for years they had no priest, and evangelicals had arrived. He told me that he went to a woman who had been the teacher of the people and then the principle of the village school.

This lady sat him down and began to insult him forcefully saying, “You abandoned us, left us alone, and I, who in need of God’s Word, had to go to Protestant worship and I became Protestant.”

This young priest, who is meek, who is one who prays, when the woman finished her discourse, said, “Madam, just one word: forgiveness. Forgive us, forgive us. We abandoned the flock.”

The tone of the woman changed. However, she remained Protestant and the priest did not go into the argument of which was the true religion. In that moment, you could not do this. In the end, the lady began to smile and said, “Father, would you like some coffee?”

“Yes, let’s have a coffee,” he replied.

Afterwards, when the priest was about to leave, she said, “Stop here, Father. Come.”

And she led him into the bedroom, opened the closet and there was the image of Our Lady.

“You should know that I never abandoned her. I hid her because of the pastor, but she’s in the home,” the lady said.

It is a story which teaches how proximity, meekness brought about this woman’s reconciliation with the Church, because she felt abandoned by the Church.

And I asked a question of this priest that you should never ask, “And then, how did things turn out? How did things finish?”

But the priest corrected me, saying, “Oh, no, I did not ask anything; she continues to go to Protestant worship, but you can see that she is a woman who prays. She faces the Lord Jesus.” And it did not go beyond that. He did not invite her to return to the Catholic Church.

What is one to make of this “advice” and the bishop giving it? Three things can be said with certainty:

1) This bishop has a very twisted understanding of what it means to be reconciled with the Church. In his mind, a woman who hides her supposed devotion to the Blessed Virgin Mary for fear of rebuke from a heretic “pastor,” and who is steadfast in “worshiping” in a heretical community, has undergone a “reconciliation with the Church” presumably because she set her anger aside long enough to have a cup of coffee with a Catholic priest.

2) This bishop has a deficient understanding of the Church’s mission. His inquisitor has been given to believe that priestly work is well done apart from inviting heretics to return to the Catholic Church and the sacraments. He furthermore has been given to believe that he can determine on his own that one outside the Church, with no possibility of being absolved from his or her sins “faces the Lord,” the presumption being that such a person is fine where they are; outside of the solitary Ark of Salvation.

3) This bishop is the current Bishop of Rome; a pope who has demonstrated time and time again an appalling lack of concern for even the most basic duties of his exalted office.

The story above was shared by Pope Francis during a Q&A session with the priests of Caserta that took place on July 26th; it’s just one of a number of things said that day by a Roman Pontiff whose prolific public discourse so often betrays his indifference to the Catholic faith. You may read the exchange in its fullness on the Vatican News website linked above, but be forewarned, it is a gut wrenching experience.

Clearly, the priests of Caserta would have done far better to email their questions to just about any commenter on this blog. (Small compliment, I know.)

Share this post on:facebooktwittergoogle_plusreddit
Follow us on:facebooktwittergoogle_plusvimeo

Latest Comments

  1. Lynda July 28, 2014
  2. my2cents July 28, 2014
  3. Matthew July 28, 2014
  4. Michael Leon July 28, 2014
  5. Indignus famulus July 28, 2014
  6. S.Armaticus July 29, 2014
  7. salvemur July 29, 2014
  8. FrA July 29, 2014
  9. my2cents July 29, 2014
  10. Indignus famulus July 29, 2014
  11. Michael Leon July 29, 2014
  12. Michael Leon July 29, 2014
  13. de Maria numquam satis July 29, 2014
  14. de Maria numquam satis July 29, 2014
  15. de Maria numquam satis July 29, 2014
  16. de Maria numquam satis July 29, 2014
  17. my2cents July 29, 2014
  18. Indignus famulus July 29, 2014
  19. salvemur July 29, 2014
  20. Michael Leon July 29, 2014
  21. Indignus famulus July 29, 2014
  22. my2cents July 29, 2014
  23. rcaamo July 29, 2014
  24. Matthew July 29, 2014
  25. Indignus famulus July 29, 2014
  26. Indignus famulus July 29, 2014
  27. Indignus famulus July 29, 2014
  28. Roman Watcher July 29, 2014
  29. Indignus famulus July 29, 2014
  30. rcaamo July 29, 2014
  31. rcaamo July 29, 2014
  32. Matthew July 29, 2014
  33. Matthew July 29, 2014
  34. S.Armaticus July 29, 2014
  35. Indignus famulus July 29, 2014
  36. Indignus famulus July 29, 2014
  37. S.Armaticus July 29, 2014
  38. Paul Morphy July 29, 2014
  39. Roman Watcher July 29, 2014
  40. Christopher July 29, 2014
  41. Indignus famulus July 29, 2014
  42. Indignus famulus July 29, 2014
  43. Indignus famulus July 29, 2014
  44. Jenny from the block July 29, 2014
  45. Indignus famulus July 29, 2014
  46. Lynda July 29, 2014
  47. Indignus famulus July 29, 2014
  48. Lynda July 29, 2014
  49. Roman Watcher July 29, 2014
  50. Indignus famulus July 29, 2014
  51. GreatPretender51 July 29, 2014
  52. A Catholic Thinker July 29, 2014
  53. Indignus famulus July 29, 2014
  54. Indignus famulus July 29, 2014
  55. joannesromanus July 29, 2014
  56. joannesromanus July 29, 2014
  57. Indignus famulus July 29, 2014
  58. Indignus famulus July 29, 2014
  59. Michael Leon July 29, 2014
  60. JamesTheLesser July 29, 2014
  61. JamesTheLesser July 29, 2014
  62. Lynda July 29, 2014
  63. Indignus famulus July 29, 2014
  64. Lynda July 29, 2014
  65. de Maria numquam satis July 29, 2014
  66. JamesTheLesser July 29, 2014
  67. de Maria numquam satis July 29, 2014
  68. Lynda July 29, 2014
  69. de Maria numquam satis July 29, 2014
  70. Matthew July 29, 2014
  71. de Maria numquam satis July 29, 2014
  72. Lynda July 29, 2014
  73. Indignus famulus July 29, 2014
  74. Indignus famulus July 29, 2014
  75. Indignus famulus July 29, 2014
  76. Michael Leon July 29, 2014
  77. de Maria numquam satis July 29, 2014
  78. Indignus famulus July 29, 2014
  79. Michael Leon July 30, 2014
  80. S.Armaticus July 30, 2014
  81. S.Armaticus July 30, 2014
  82. Michael Leon July 30, 2014
  83. Michael Leon July 30, 2014
  84. Michael Leon July 30, 2014
  85. Johnno July 30, 2014
  86. Michael Leon July 30, 2014
  87. Michael Leon July 30, 2014
  88. Michael Leon July 30, 2014
  89. FrA July 30, 2014
  90. S.Armaticus July 30, 2014
  91. de Maria numquam satis July 30, 2014
  92. Matthew July 30, 2014
  93. Indignus famulus July 30, 2014
  94. Indignus famulus July 30, 2014
  95. Indignus famulus July 30, 2014
  96. JamesTheLesser July 30, 2014
  97. Lynda July 30, 2014
  98. Indignus famulus July 30, 2014
  99. Indignus famulus July 30, 2014
  100. Indignus famulus July 30, 2014
  101. Lynda July 30, 2014
  102. Lynda July 30, 2014
  103. Michael Leon July 30, 2014
  104. salvemur July 30, 2014
  105. Indignus famulus July 31, 2014
  106. Indignus famulus July 31, 2014
  107. Indignus famulus July 31, 2014
  108. Indignus famulus July 31, 2014
  109. Indignus famulus July 31, 2014
  110. de Maria numquam satis July 31, 2014
  111. Roman Watcher July 31, 2014
  112. Ontarienne69 July 31, 2014
  113. Ontarienne69 July 31, 2014
  114. Ontarienne69 July 31, 2014
  115. Ontarienne69 July 31, 2014
  116. Matthew July 31, 2014
  117. Indignus famulus July 31, 2014
  118. Indignus famulus July 31, 2014
  119. Indignus famulus July 31, 2014
  120. Indignus famulus July 31, 2014
  121. Ontarienne69 August 1, 2014
  122. Indignus famulus August 1, 2014
  123. Lynda August 1, 2014
  124. Lynda August 1, 2014
  125. Lynda August 1, 2014
  126. Lynda August 1, 2014
  127. Indignus famulus August 2, 2014
  128. Indignus famulus August 2, 2014
  129. Lynda August 3, 2014