Bishop Fellay: A troubling interview

fellay-csjOn June 30th – ten days prior to being replaced as SSPX Superior General, Bishop Bernard Fellay was interviewed by the German media outlet Die Tagespost. An English translation of the complete text of the interview is available on the Society’s website.

Here, we will look at a number of relevant excerpts; some of them very troubling.

First observation – Die Tagespost is not a “traditionalist” publication; rather, it is neo-conservative in orientation. As such, this interview provided a golden opportunity for His Excellency to speak plainly to those who are convinced that the Second Vatican Council and the Novus Ordo Missae are not in and of themselves poisonous.

In fact, I would say that this is the only good reason to sit down with an interviewer that one can reasonably expect to be antagonistic – in this case, a writer by the name of Regina Einig – and indeed, she was.

Einig was not bashful about showing her bias by suggesting, and stubbornly so even after being corrected, that there was a “definitive separation of the Society” from the Church.

Bishop Fellay did well to state firmly, “I insist: We never separated from the Church,” and this after already having said of the 1988 consecrations:

Therefore it was not about separating from the Church, but about distinguishing our position from the modern spirit, from the fruits of the Council.

This may cause one to wonder: Spirit, fruits, or contents of the Council? Bishop Fellay went on to clarify, as he stated:

We never said that the Council made heretical statements outright. But it did remove the protective barrier against error and in this way caused error to crop up.

Wow. Count me as stunned. If it is not an outright heresy to say that Christ uses the Protestant sects as “means of salvation” (Unitatis Redintegration – 3) then nothing is.

Of course, there are those who will split hairs (as Fr. Gleize did on behalf of the SSPX in his treatment of Amoris Laetitia) by framing the definition of “heresy” in such theologically technical terms that the word is rendered all-but-meaningless.

Even so, the more troubling aspect of Bishop Fellay’s response concerns the suggestion that the Council simply “removed barriers against error;” as opposed to positively proposing error.

What happened to Bishop Fellay?!

I recall very well having had the privilege of sharing a semi-private breakfast with His Excellency and just four or five others (all priests but one) back in 2012. At the time, I was still in the earlier stages of having my eyes opened to tradition, and I remember vividly just how jolting it was to hear Bishop Fellay speak plainly about “the errors of the Council.”

In fact, the Decree on Ecumenism and the preposterous idea that the Protestant sects are “means of salvation” is one of the specific examples he cited in so accusing the Council.

Today, not only does he suggest otherwise, he actually went on in the interview to explicitly absolve the Council of error:

…what happened during and after the Council was perceived much more sensitively and more attentively than in Germany. It was not a matter of blatant errors, but rather of trends, of opening doors and windows.

As much as I would like to report otherwise, it only went from bad to worse.

After clarifying the Society’s position on the Novus Ordo (generally valid, but harmful), he went on to say:

The new Mass has defects and dangers lurking in it. Of course not every new Mass is a scandal immediately, but the repeated celebration of the new Mass leads to a weak faith or even to the loss of faith.

If I may take the liberty of clarifying Bishop Fellay’s point, at least in terms of what I believe it is fair to imagine, in suggesting that every new Mass is not “a scandal immediately,” he seems to mean that the faithful there present are not immediately scandalized. This, as most of us know from experience, is true; i.e., it is often only over time that one’s eyes are opened that the reality of the Novus Ordo.

That said, we must be clear (and, unfortunately, Bishop Fellay was not): The Novus Ordo, given the undeniable fact that it is defective and leads one away from the Faith, is always and everywhere scandalous – no matter how it is celebrated.

Bishop Fellay went on to list a number of examples of how the new Mass leads to a loss of faith. He then said:

With the new Mass you have to bring your own faith; you receive hardly anything immediately from the rite. The rite is flat.

Not to nitpick, but after having participated in the Novus Ordo for more than a decade, I know that this isn’t true. The anthropocentric orientation of the new Mass always presses itself upon those present – even when celebrated ad orientem. It is inescapable.

When asked by Einig, “Do you consider conversions that are encouraged even today by the new Mass—think of Nightfever [a spin-off from World Youth Day that organizes nights of prayer to bring people back to the faith]—to be self-deceptions?

A good answer to that question would have made it clear that any conversions that appear to grow out of the Novus Ordo are evidence of God’s goodness and generosity; they are not indications that the rite is an instrument of conversion; much less good. And then there is the question: To exactly what are those persons converting?

In any case, Bishop Fellay answered:

No, I’m not saying that. I’m just saying: If you welcome a head of state and have the choice between a silver trumpet and a tin trumpet, do you use the tin trumpet? That would be an insult; you don’t do that. And even the best new Masses are like tin trumpets in comparison to the old liturgy. We have to use the best for the dear Lord.

Perhaps this was an attempt to engage Die Tagespost’s neo-conservative audience by framing the conversation in terms of what Our Lord deserves. Indeed, it is true that the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass is the summit of Divine worship; it is the best that we have to offer Him.

The problem, however, lies in the suggestion that the difference between the Traditional Roman Rite and the Novus Oro lies not so much in what they are as in the quality of each; like in the case of a Toyota Prius and a Cadillac – each one a car that will get you where you want go, but one a whole lot nicer than the other.

According to this way of thinking, both rites are truly Catholic; one is just more impressive in the eyes of God.

I don’t think that Bishop Fellay believes this to be so, but then again, based on the contents of this interview, I must admit that I no longer have any confidence in my own perception concerning what he actually believes or not.

There is, however, an even bigger problem.

As I have stated in the past, a sincere seeker of truth who happens to come upon this interview, or certain other pieces of information posted on the SSPX website, will likely come away not knowing what the Society itself actually believes – and worse, what is, and what is not, consonant with tradition.

In conclusion, please pray for Bishop Fellay. Clearly, all is not well with him. Let us pray also for the Society, that under the leadership of Fr. Pagliarani it will once again speak with clarity and conviction in defense of Catholic tradition.

IMPORTANT NOTE: The launch of The Catholic Inquisitor has led to a decrease in content posted at akaCatholic. Eventually, this will not be the case. In addition to costing time, the newspaper is taking a financial toll. I knew it would and accept this challenge willingly, trusting that Our Lord will – as He always has – raise up the supporters that we need. If you feel so compelled, now would be a great time to donate. – Louie

aka IMPACT

Share this post on:facebooktwittergoogle_plusreddit
Follow us on:facebooktwittergoogle_plusvimeo

Latest Comments

  1. Akita July 31, 2018
  2. LennyB July 31, 2018
    • Lynda July 31, 2018
    • FromPoland July 31, 2018
      • sweepoutthefilth July 31, 2018
        • FromPoland July 31, 2018
          • FromPoland July 31, 2018
          • sweepoutthefilth July 31, 2018
          • FromPoland July 31, 2018
          • Ratio August 1, 2018
        • 2Vermont July 31, 2018
          • sweepoutthefilth July 31, 2018
          • sweepoutthefilth July 31, 2018
      • Stonka Ziemniaczana August 2, 2018
  3. 2Vermont July 31, 2018
    • FromPoland July 31, 2018
      • sweepoutthefilth July 31, 2018
      • sweepoutthefilth August 1, 2018
        • sweepoutthefilth August 1, 2018
      • sweepoutthekilts August 1, 2018
  4. Evangeline July 31, 2018
    • MMC July 31, 2018
  5. my2cents July 31, 2018
  6. Michael Wilson July 31, 2018
  7. The Great Stalin July 31, 2018
    • sweepoutthefilth August 1, 2018
      • The Great Stalin August 1, 2018
        • sweepoutthefilth August 1, 2018
  8. FatherMonk August 1, 2018
  9. my2cents August 1, 2018
  10. Ratio August 1, 2018
    • Evangeline August 1, 2018
      • Ratio August 3, 2018
  11. Ignatio August 1, 2018
    • sweepoutthekilts August 1, 2018
      • my2cents August 1, 2018
  12. FromPoland August 1, 2018
  13. sweepoutthefilth August 1, 2018
  14. sweepoutthefilth August 1, 2018
    • LennyB August 1, 2018
      • sweepoutthefilth August 1, 2018
  15. 2Vermont August 1, 2018
  16. LennyB August 1, 2018
  17. sweepoutthefilth August 1, 2018
  18. my2cents August 1, 2018
    • sweepoutthefilth August 1, 2018
    • The Great Stalin August 2, 2018
    • 2Vermont August 2, 2018
  19. Pascendi August 2, 2018
    • Lynda August 2, 2018
  20. Pascendi August 2, 2018
  21. my2cents August 2, 2018
    • 2Vermont August 2, 2018
      • sweepoutthefilth August 2, 2018
  22. my2cents August 2, 2018
    • sweepoutthefilth August 2, 2018
  23. my2cents August 2, 2018
    • sweepoutthefilth August 2, 2018
      • sweepoutthekilts August 2, 2018
        • sweepoutthefilth August 2, 2018
          • sweepoutthefilth August 2, 2018
          • sweepoutthekilts August 2, 2018
          • sweepoutthekilts August 2, 2018
      • Lynda August 2, 2018
  24. The Great Stalin August 2, 2018
  25. sweepoutthefilth August 2, 2018
  26. Tom A August 2, 2018
    • Stonka Ziemniaczana August 2, 2018
  27. The Great Stalin August 2, 2018
    • sweepoutthefilth August 2, 2018
      • Lynda August 2, 2018
    • Ursula August 2, 2018
  28. Stonka Ziemniaczana August 2, 2018
  29. Lynda August 2, 2018
  30. Lynda August 2, 2018
    • The Great Stalin August 3, 2018
  31. Katherine August 3, 2018

Leave a Reply