The imprisonment of the FFI continues

FREE FFIOn June 10th Pope Francis met with roughly 60 Franciscans of the Immaculate along with the man he appointed to oversee the order as Pontifical Commissioner, Fr. Fidenzio Volpi.

The most detailed account of the meeting to be published to date comes from Andrea Tornielli of La Stampa, some excerpts of which follow.

Pope Bergoglio proved to be well informed on all issues, following the matter closely, and several times showed his appreciation for father Volpi, quelling rumours that the actions of the government of the commissioner and his collaborators were undertaken without the Pope’s knowledge.

Based on the steady stream of unvarnished hostility flowing from the lips of Pope Francis toward traditionalists (aka Catholics) over the entire length of his fifteen month pontificate, has there ever been any reason to doubt the influence of his hand in the mistreatment of the FFI? I never did.

On the motu proprio, Pope Francis said he did not want to deviate from the line of Benedict XVI, and reiterated that the Franciscan Friars of the Immaculate remained free to celebrate the old mass, even if for the moment, in light of the controversies surrounding the exclusive right to use that missal – an element that did not constitute part of the founding charisma of the institution – they required “a discernment” with the superior and with the bishop if it concerned celebrations in parish churches, sanctuaries and teaching houses.

In other words, the pope told the prisoners that they are free to travel abroad, even if for the moment they must first seek the gatekeeper’s permission, which may or may not be given, to have the cell unlocked and the shackles removed from their ankles.

Needless to say, anyone who has ever taken the time to read Summorrum Pontificum knows perfectly well that the restrictions under which the FFI are being required to operate are the very definition of a “deviation” from “the line of Benedict XVI.”

No surprise here. The neo-modernists as a whole, in case you haven’t noticed, whether in a parish setting, a diocesan office, or a pontifical commission in Rome, operate from the presumption that they are the smartest, most well-informed people in the room.

The Pope explained that there must be freedom, both for those who wish to celebrate with the old rite, and those who wish to celebrate with the new rite, without the rite becoming an ideological banner.

Without becoming an ideological banner… This phrase falls squarely into the “doth protesteth too much” category; otherwise known in Freudian terminology as “psychological projection.”

You see, for intrepid protectors of tradition like Cardinal Ottaviani, Cardinal Bacci and Archbishop Lefebvre; men for whom Christ Our Redeemer and King always occupied first place, when it came to the Novus Ordo, their concern centered around an awareness that the rite “deviates most seriously from the theology of the Catholic Mass.” (cf “Ottaviani Intervention” sent to Pope Paul VI on Sept. 25, 1969)

Those, on the other hand, who operate under the influence of that conciliar poison which causes one to behave as if “all things on earth should be related to man as their center and crown” (Gaudium et Spes – 12), the same individuals who are determined to shove this deficient rite down our collective throats, for them the eye of the current liturgical hurricane most certainly rotates around concerns ideological; i.e., earthbound matters pertaining almost exclusively to the social order.

One question concerned the interpretation of the II Vatican Council … He then responded to the objection according to which the II Vatican would only be a castoral council, which has damaged the church.

A “castoral” council. Ha! This no doubt innocent typographical error has just found a new home in the Tradwriter’s lexicon.

Castoral Council: (noun) A council of the Holy Catholic Church, the net result of which is the swift and effective detesticulation of her sacred pastors.

I’m sure that an opportunity to put it in play will present itself soon enough.

He then reminded them that all councils have provoked uproar and reactions, because the demon “does not want the church to become strong”. He also said that we must move forwards with a theological and not ideological hermeneutic of the II Vatican.

So many claims…

All councils have provoked uproar and reactions.

Yes, but let us not forget that Vatican Council II is unique in that it was a castoral exercise. (Wow, that didn’t take long.)

Seriously, there is no comparison to be made between the likes of the Nicea and Constantinople Councils and Vatican II as the latter was not called upon, in the face of certain heresies, to settle profound doctrinal questions via the issuance of dogmatic definitions.

Why on earth would a council charged with rearticulating the well-established sacred deposit of Christian doctrine “pure and integral, without any attenuation or distortion” provoke uproar and reactions in the Church?

There’s only one reason; it didn’t.

The demon “does not want the church to become strong.”

This is absolutely correct, which is precisely why the demon has been dancing with delight ever since the Vicars of Christ, from Paul VI to Francis, chose to hang their zucchetti almost exclusively on the text of a council that managed, in the course of roughly three years, to confuse the doctrine of the faith as established with precision and clarity over the course of the preceding nineteen centuries.

We must move forwards with a theological and not ideological…   

Always with the ideology, this one!

Francis also said that he had wanted the closure of the theological institute within the Franciscans of the Immaculate (STIM), so that the seminarists would study in the pontifical theology faculties of Rome. He then explained that the Church guarantees orthodoxy through the Pope.

Ah, yes… “the pontifical theology faculties of Rome,” wherein every tradition-minded instructor, well aware of the screws that have been tightened upon the FFI, walks on egg shells for fear of inviting suspicion of having their own crypto-Lefebvrian tendencies.

And let’s get something straight: While it may be said that the authority vested in the Petrine Office, when legitimately exercised in service to the doctrine of the faith as guardian and teacher, is a guarantor of orthodoxy; every individual pope at any given time? Not so much.

Pope Francis? You decide.

Share this post on:facebooktwittergoogle_plusreddit
Follow us on:facebooktwittergoogle_plusvimeo

Latest Comments

  1. Indignus famulus June 26, 2014
  2. Indignus famulus June 26, 2014
  3. bigfred June 26, 2014
  4. bigfred June 26, 2014
  5. JamesTheLesser June 26, 2014
  6. rcaamo June 26, 2014
  7. Indignus famulus June 26, 2014
  8. Matthew June 26, 2014
  9. JamesTheLesser June 26, 2014
  10. Indignus famulus June 26, 2014
  11. JamesTheLesser June 26, 2014
  12. S.Armaticus June 27, 2014
  13. Michael Leon June 27, 2014
  14. Indignus famulus June 27, 2014
  15. rcaamo June 27, 2014
  16. Matthew June 27, 2014
  17. salvemur June 27, 2014
  18. salvemur June 27, 2014
  19. salvemur June 27, 2014
  20. Matthew June 27, 2014
  21. rcaamo June 27, 2014
  22. Indignus famulus June 27, 2014
  23. Matthew June 27, 2014
  24. JamesTheLesser June 27, 2014
  25. Indignus famulus June 27, 2014
  26. Matthew June 27, 2014
  27. JamesTheLesser June 27, 2014
  28. Indignus famulus June 27, 2014
  29. Indignus famulus June 27, 2014
  30. salvemur June 27, 2014
  31. salvemur June 27, 2014
  32. salvemur June 27, 2014
  33. salvemur June 27, 2014
  34. salvemur June 27, 2014
  35. Michael Leon June 27, 2014
  36. salvemur June 28, 2014
  37. salvemur June 28, 2014
  38. salvemur June 28, 2014
  39. salvemur June 28, 2014
  40. salvemur June 28, 2014
  41. JamesTheLesser June 28, 2014
  42. salvemur June 28, 2014
  43. salvemur June 28, 2014
  44. salvemur June 28, 2014
  45. Indignus famulus June 28, 2014
  46. JamesTheLesser June 28, 2014
  47. salvemur June 28, 2014
  48. salvemur June 28, 2014
  49. Indignus famulus June 28, 2014
  50. salvemur June 28, 2014
  51. Indignus famulus June 28, 2014
  52. salvemur June 28, 2014
  53. Indignus famulus June 28, 2014
  54. Indignus famulus June 28, 2014
  55. JamesTheLesser June 28, 2014
  56. Indignus famulus June 28, 2014
  57. Cyprian June 28, 2014
  58. Indignus famulus June 28, 2014
  59. bigfred June 28, 2014
  60. bigfred June 28, 2014
  61. S.Armaticus June 28, 2014
  62. JamesTheLesser June 28, 2014
  63. Indignus famulus June 28, 2014
  64. Cyprian June 28, 2014
  65. bigfred June 28, 2014
  66. bigfred June 28, 2014
  67. Matthew June 28, 2014
  68. A Catholic Thinker June 28, 2014
  69. A Catholic Thinker June 28, 2014
  70. A Catholic Thinker June 28, 2014
  71. Matthew June 28, 2014
  72. A Catholic Thinker June 28, 2014
  73. Indignus famulus June 28, 2014
  74. Indignus famulus June 28, 2014
  75. A Catholic Thinker June 28, 2014
  76. Cyprian June 28, 2014
  77. Cyprian June 28, 2014
  78. Indignus famulus June 28, 2014
  79. Cyprian June 28, 2014
  80. bigfred June 28, 2014
  81. Indignus famulus June 28, 2014
  82. JamesTheLesser June 28, 2014
  83. A Catholic Thinker June 28, 2014
  84. A Catholic Thinker June 28, 2014
  85. JamesTheLesser June 28, 2014
  86. bigfred June 28, 2014
  87. A Catholic Thinker June 28, 2014
  88. bigfred June 28, 2014
  89. bigfred June 28, 2014
  90. A Catholic Thinker June 28, 2014
  91. A Catholic Thinker June 28, 2014
  92. A Catholic Thinker June 28, 2014
  93. bigfred June 28, 2014
  94. A Catholic Thinker June 28, 2014
  95. Cyprian June 28, 2014
  96. bigfred June 28, 2014
  97. bigfred June 28, 2014
  98. A Catholic Thinker June 28, 2014
  99. bigfred June 28, 2014
  100. Matthew June 28, 2014
  101. Cyprian June 28, 2014
  102. bigfred June 28, 2014
  103. A Catholic Thinker June 28, 2014
  104. A Catholic Thinker June 28, 2014
  105. A Catholic Thinker June 28, 2014
  106. bigfred June 28, 2014
  107. bigfred June 28, 2014
  108. bigfred June 28, 2014
  109. bigfred June 28, 2014
  110. Munda Cor Meum June 28, 2014
  111. Matthew June 28, 2014
  112. Cyprian June 28, 2014
  113. Cyprian June 28, 2014
  114. A Catholic Thinker June 28, 2014
  115. A Catholic Thinker June 28, 2014
  116. Indignus famulus June 28, 2014
  117. A Catholic Thinker June 28, 2014
  118. A Catholic Thinker June 28, 2014
  119. A Catholic Thinker June 28, 2014
  120. A Catholic Thinker June 28, 2014
  121. Indignus famulus June 28, 2014
  122. Cyprian June 28, 2014
  123. Indignus famulus June 28, 2014
  124. Indignus famulus June 28, 2014
  125. A Catholic Thinker June 28, 2014
  126. A Catholic Thinker June 28, 2014
  127. A Catholic Thinker June 28, 2014
  128. A Catholic Thinker June 28, 2014
  129. A Catholic Thinker June 28, 2014
  130. Cyprian June 28, 2014
  131. bigfred June 28, 2014
  132. bigfred June 28, 2014
  133. bigfred June 28, 2014
  134. Cyprian June 28, 2014
  135. Indignus famulus June 28, 2014
  136. A Catholic Thinker June 28, 2014
  137. A Catholic Thinker June 28, 2014
  138. Indignus famulus June 28, 2014
  139. JamesTheLesser June 28, 2014
  140. JamesTheLesser June 28, 2014
  141. JamesTheLesser June 28, 2014
  142. JamesTheLesser June 28, 2014
  143. JamesTheLesser June 28, 2014
  144. JamesTheLesser June 28, 2014
  145. JamesTheLesser June 28, 2014
  146. A Catholic Thinker June 28, 2014
  147. Cyprian June 29, 2014
  148. salvemur June 29, 2014
  149. salvemur June 29, 2014
  150. salvemur June 29, 2014
  151. salvemur June 29, 2014
  152. salvemur June 29, 2014
  153. salvemur June 29, 2014
  154. A Catholic Thinker June 29, 2014
  155. A Catholic Thinker June 29, 2014
  156. salvemur June 29, 2014
  157. salvemur June 29, 2014
  158. salvemur June 29, 2014
  159. salvemur June 29, 2014
  160. salvemur June 29, 2014
  161. salvemur June 29, 2014
  162. salvemur June 29, 2014
  163. salvemur June 29, 2014
  164. salvemur June 29, 2014
  165. S.Armaticus June 29, 2014
  166. bigfred June 29, 2014
  167. bigfred June 29, 2014
  168. bigfred June 29, 2014
  169. bigfred June 29, 2014
  170. bigfred June 29, 2014
  171. bigfred June 29, 2014
  172. salvemur June 29, 2014
  173. Edu June 29, 2014
  174. Edu June 29, 2014
  175. A Catholic Thinker June 29, 2014
  176. A Catholic Thinker June 29, 2014
  177. A Catholic Thinker June 29, 2014
  178. Cyprian June 29, 2014
  179. de Maria numquam satis June 29, 2014
  180. de Maria numquam satis June 29, 2014
  181. de Maria numquam satis June 29, 2014
  182. Edu June 29, 2014
  183. de Maria numquam satis June 29, 2014
  184. rcaamo June 29, 2014
  185. Indignus famulus June 29, 2014
  186. Indignus famulus June 29, 2014
  187. Lynda June 29, 2014
  188. A Catholic Thinker June 29, 2014
  189. rcaamo June 29, 2014
  190. salvemur June 30, 2014
  191. salvemur June 30, 2014
  192. salvemur June 30, 2014
  193. salvemur June 30, 2014
  194. salvemur June 30, 2014
  195. Michael Leon June 30, 2014
  196. Indignus famulus June 30, 2014
  197. Indignus famulus June 30, 2014
  198. bigfred June 30, 2014
  199. bigfred June 30, 2014
  200. bigfred June 30, 2014
  201. bigfred June 30, 2014
  202. bigfred June 30, 2014
  203. Indignus famulus June 30, 2014
  204. Indignus famulus June 30, 2014
  205. Indignus famulus June 30, 2014
  206. bigfred June 30, 2014
  207. bigfred June 30, 2014
  208. rcaamo June 30, 2014
  209. Indignus famulus June 30, 2014
  210. Indignus famulus June 30, 2014
  211. Indignus famulus June 30, 2014
  212. Indignus famulus June 30, 2014
  213. Louie June 30, 2014