POLL: Your thoughts on Benedict’s resignation

Ben Resign
In the aftermath of Archbishop Gänswein’s stunning confirmation concerning the intentions of Pope Benedict XVI with respect to his resignation, it has become perfectly clear that confusion is the order of the day; with well-meaning, good people drawing varying conclusions.

I want to know what you think.

As I wrote in a recent post, if we incorporate into Benedict’s original Declaratio some of the clarity provided by Archbishop Gänswein, his statement would have been something like this:

I hereby declare that I am taking a step that has never before been taken by a pope:

With full freedom I renounce the ministry of Bishop of Rome, Successor of Saint Peter, entrusted to me by the Cardinals on 19 April 2005. However, I am not abandoning the Office of Peter — something which would be entirely impossible for me. Rather, my intent is to profoundly and permanently transform the Petrine ministry; expanding it, so as to include an ‘active member’ to be chosen in an upcoming conclave, while I myself shall remain a participant in said munus as the ‘contemplative member.’

In this way, I shall endow the papacy with a collegial and synodal dimension, as a quasi-shared ministry. Allow me to repeat it once again — my intent is entirely different from that of Pope Celestine V, who after his resignation in 1294 would have liked to return to being a hermit. I, by contrast, shall continue to live within the Vatican; I shall continue to wear the white papal cassock, and I shall continue to be addressed as His Holiness.

With this in mind, please answer the following. You may choose up to two answers.

Feel free to elaborate on your answer in the comment section, and if you’re so inclined, please invite friends who may not be regular reads to weigh-in as well. (One need not be registered in order to vote.)

If Pope Benedict XVI had presented his intentions as such on 11 February 2013, what conslusions would you have drawn about its effect on the Petrine Ministry and the See of Peter moving forward, as well as the conclave that followed?
Share this post on:facebooktwittergoogle_plusreddit
Follow us on:facebooktwittergoogle_plusvimeo

Latest Comments

  1. Rushintuit June 25, 2016
    • tradprofessor June 25, 2016
    • GMU June 28, 2016
  2. Johnno June 25, 2016
    • DavidPorter June 25, 2016
      • Johnno June 25, 2016
  3. TC June 25, 2016
    • TC June 25, 2016
      • rich June 25, 2016
        • GeorgeB June 25, 2016
          • rich June 25, 2016
          • Fiat July 15, 2016
        • Akita June 25, 2016
          • Akita June 25, 2016
          • Akita June 25, 2016
          • rich June 25, 2016
        • Akita June 26, 2016
          • Truth Seeker June 28, 2016
      • GMU June 27, 2016
    • Johnno June 25, 2016
      • rich June 25, 2016
        • Johnno June 25, 2016
          • rich June 25, 2016
          • rich June 25, 2016
          • TC June 26, 2016
          • GMU June 27, 2016
  4. remnantclergy June 25, 2016
  5. mpoulin June 25, 2016
  6. mpoulin June 25, 2016
  7. Bosco49 June 25, 2016
  8. DavidPorter June 25, 2016
    • Johnno June 25, 2016
    • TC June 26, 2016
  9. my2cents June 25, 2016
  10. Rushintuit June 25, 2016
    • rich June 25, 2016
    • TC June 26, 2016
      • A Critical Thinker June 27, 2016
    • Truth Seeker June 28, 2016
  11. my2cents June 25, 2016
    • rich June 25, 2016
      • my2cents June 25, 2016
        • rich June 25, 2016
          • TC June 26, 2016
          • rich June 27, 2016
  12. Rushintuit June 25, 2016
    • rich June 25, 2016
      • A Critical Thinker June 27, 2016
        • rich June 27, 2016
  13. rich June 25, 2016
    • A Critical Thinker June 27, 2016
      • rich June 27, 2016
  14. rich June 25, 2016
    • my2cents June 26, 2016
      • Rushintuit June 26, 2016
        • rich June 27, 2016
      • rich June 27, 2016
    • A Critical Thinker June 27, 2016
      • rich June 27, 2016
        • rich June 27, 2016
  15. VRasz June 26, 2016
  16. TC June 26, 2016
    • VRasz June 26, 2016
      • helpusLord June 26, 2016
  17. Gertrude June 26, 2016
    • A Critical Thinker June 27, 2016
  18. MMC June 26, 2016
  19. my2cents June 26, 2016
  20. Johnno June 26, 2016
    • rich June 27, 2016
      • Johnno June 27, 2016
        • rich June 27, 2016
  21. Johnno June 26, 2016
    • TC June 27, 2016
      • rich July 15, 2016
  22. Mornac June 26, 2016
  23. GeorgeB June 27, 2016
  24. GeorgeB June 27, 2016
  25. my2cents June 27, 2016
    • rich June 27, 2016
      • my2cents June 27, 2016
        • rich June 27, 2016
  26. Theresa June 27, 2016
  27. Paul Morphy June 30, 2016

Leave a Reply