BREAKING: Francis plainly accused of heresy

Francis sneerAs has recently been made public, and will no doubt dominate Catholic (and perhaps much of secular) media in the coming days, a “FILIAL CORRECTION OF POPE FRANCIS For the Propagation of Heresies,” has been issued.

The document bears the signature of some fifty noteworthy individuals; many of whom are clergy.

The text of the Correction is lengthy and very detailed; even going so far as to call Francis to account for his “unprecedented sympathy for Martin Luther” and his own flawed theology. I would encourage you to read it in full when you’re able.

Here, I wish to provide just a brief and necessarily limited “first glance” overview.

One will note that the text of the “Correction” is dated July 16, 2017, and was delivered to Francis on August 11, 2017.

NB: This document was in Francis’ hand for more than a month prior to his motu proprio reconfiguring the John Paul II Institute on Marriage and Family – the same issued with the specific intent of implementing the very heresies outlined in the Correction.

In other words, the message being sent is beyond clear:

Francis intends to forge ahead with the implementation of Amoris Laetitia in spite of having been made aware of the nature and gravity of the heresies it contains. This, my friends, is pertinacity, plain and simple.

The language employed in the Correction suggests that its authors wish, and rightly so, to carefully avoid judging Francis’ intent.

As its title indicates, it charges Francis with the “propagation of heresies;” which could perhaps be taken to mean that he is guilty, not of teaching heresy per se, but of “favens haeresim” or simply “promoting heresy” (as Fr. Jean-Michel Gleize, SSPX, famously concluded).

And yet, the Correction seems to go quite a bit further.

For one, it states the following:

Scandal concerning faith and morals has been given to the Church and to the world by the publication of Amoris laetitia and by other acts through which Your Holiness has sufficiently made clear the scope and purpose of this document.

NB: The Correction claims that Francis “has sufficiently made clear the scope and purpose” of Amoris Laetitia.

This is striking in that it comes very close to making a judgment as to intent.

Elsewhere, the text offers yet another strong statement:

Our correction is indeed required by fidelity to infallible papal teachings which are incompatible with certain of Your Holiness’s statements.

This, however, comes immediately after citing “the heresies which this exhortation insinuates.”

One could not be faulted for coming away confused:

Does the exhortation merely “insinuate” heresies, or is it objectively “incompatible with infallible papal teachings”?

After going on to list seven specific erroneous propositions in the text of Amoris Laetitia (while making it a point to say that this list does not cover all of the faults to be found in the text) the Correction states:

These propositions all contradict truths that are divinely revealed, and that Catholics must believe with the assent of divine faith.

Taken as a whole, the language of the Correction leaves little doubt:

The seven propositions listed constitute the very definition of heresy; i.e., heresy is not merely “insinuated,” it is present.

NOTE: I will not list the seven propositions here, but rather will invite you to explore the Correction directly. Regular readers of this space will find that they are the very propositions that we have been discussing since April 2016.

IMPORTANT: The Correction contains a truly curious comment relative to the doubts being cast upon the Petrine Office in our day:

Others again of the faithful are led to put in doubt the validity of the renunciation of the papacy by Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI.

I, for one, find it rather intriguing that the controversy surrounding Benedict’s resignation is given mention in this text.

Clearly, whether Benedict validly resigned or not has absolutely no bearing whatsoever on the objective sense of the text of Amoris Laetitia.

So, why is it mentioned?

Is this a warning shot of sorts; included to let Francis know that a less-than-desirable response on his part may invite inquiry into the validity of his papacy?

Whatever the case may be, that the controversy is given mention in this text only serves to indicate the degree to which serious thinkers are questioning the matter of Benedict’s resignation, and may very well be prepared to delve more deeply into its validity moving forward.

And now for the “money quote” in the entire lengthy document:

We respectfully insist that Your Holiness publicly reject these [seven heretical] propositions.

NB: The days of respectfully “requesting” that Francis provide “clarity” are over.

Here, it is being insisted upon that Francis publicly reject the very heresies that he himself promulgated in the text of Amoris Laetitia.

Lastly, for now, one will note that missing from the list of signatories (some of whom, to be perfectly candid, do not carry a great deal of gravitas, in part, thanks to their weak public responses to AL as given in previous months) are any members of the College of Cardinals; most notably Cardinals Brandmuller and Burke.

This Correction, in other words, is not to be confused with the “formal declaration” that Cardinal Burke promised in light of Francis’ continued failure to formally respond to the Dubia.

So, where will we go from here?

Time alone will tell, but one would be naïve to believe that Francis will respond directly.

Again, let us not forget that he has had this text in hand for over a month now, and he responded by doubling down as I wrote just last week.

Stay tuned.

aka focus

Latest Comments

  1. John314 September 24, 2017
  2. my2cents September 24, 2017
  3. Tom A September 24, 2017
  4. john6 September 24, 2017
  5. mpoulin September 24, 2017
  6. my2cents September 24, 2017
  7. Semper Fidelis September 24, 2017
  8. mpoulin September 24, 2017
  9. Semper Fidelis September 24, 2017
  10. In caritas September 24, 2017
  11. In caritas September 24, 2017
  12. maryiloveher September 24, 2017
  13. cgib September 24, 2017
  14. Akita September 24, 2017
  15. mpoulin September 24, 2017
  16. Ursula September 24, 2017
  17. AlphonsusJr September 24, 2017
  18. Francesco dAssisi September 24, 2017
  19. irishpol September 24, 2017
  20. Semper Fidelis September 24, 2017
  21. Tom A September 24, 2017
  22. my2cents September 24, 2017
  23. AlphonsusJr September 24, 2017
  24. JTLiuzza September 24, 2017
  25. Rushintuit September 24, 2017
  26. Rushintuit September 24, 2017
  27. VCR September 24, 2017
  28. Tom A September 24, 2017
  29. johnAU September 24, 2017
  30. rich September 24, 2017
  31. sweepoutthefilth September 24, 2017
  32. Al The Silent Crusader September 24, 2017
  33. my2cents September 24, 2017
  34. In caritas September 24, 2017
  35. tradprofessor September 24, 2017
  36. Akita September 24, 2017
  37. Akita September 24, 2017
  38. Ad Jesum Per Mariam September 24, 2017
  39. In caritas September 24, 2017
  40. johnAU September 24, 2017
  41. al bon September 25, 2017
  42. al bon September 25, 2017
  43. Esteban September 25, 2017
  44. Esteban September 25, 2017
  45. Esteban September 25, 2017
  46. Esteban September 25, 2017
  47. Esteban September 25, 2017
  48. Akita September 25, 2017
  49. Tom A September 25, 2017
  50. Tom A September 25, 2017
  51. Rushintuit September 25, 2017
  52. Tom A September 25, 2017
  53. Rushintuit September 25, 2017
  54. Johnno September 25, 2017
  55. my2cents September 25, 2017
  56. rich September 25, 2017
  57. In caritas September 25, 2017
  58. In caritas September 25, 2017
  59. AlphonsusJr September 25, 2017
  60. fast ferrari September 25, 2017
  61. fast ferrari September 25, 2017
  62. Johnno September 26, 2017
  63. Tom A September 27, 2017
  64. In caritas September 27, 2017
  65. In caritas September 27, 2017
  66. Johnno September 28, 2017
  67. Johnno September 28, 2017
  68. Johnno September 28, 2017
  69. Tom A September 28, 2017
  70. In caritas September 28, 2017
  71. Johnno September 29, 2017
  72. Johnno September 29, 2017
  73. Tom A September 29, 2017
  74. In caritas September 29, 2017
  75. Ursula September 30, 2017
  76. Tom A September 30, 2017
  77. In caritas September 30, 2017
  78. Tom A September 30, 2017
  79. Ursula September 30, 2017
  80. Johnno September 30, 2017
  81. Johnno September 30, 2017
  82. Johnno September 30, 2017
  83. Johnno September 30, 2017
  84. In caritas September 30, 2017
  85. Johnno September 30, 2017
  86. Johnno September 30, 2017
  87. In caritas September 30, 2017
  88. Johnno September 30, 2017
  89. Johnno September 30, 2017
  90. In caritas September 30, 2017
  91. In caritas September 30, 2017
  92. johnjobilbee September 30, 2017
  93. Johnno October 5, 2017
  94. Tom A October 7, 2017