Bishop Athanasius Schneider: Coward or Hero?

Bishop Schneider lgOn February 2, Bishop Athanasius Schneider – “our hero,” according to Michael Matt, Founder of the #UNITEtheCONS movement – published a statement calling on Francis to rule decisively against the German bishops’ plans to enact the so-called “Synodal Path.”

According to Bishop Schneider, the “synodal path is ultimately an attempt to give official approval to truly heretical doctrines, with their correspondent sacramental and pastoral practices.” Specifically, he pointed to the effort to affirm “the legitimacy of heterosexual acts outside a valid marriage” and “the admittance to Holy Communion of people living in adultery” as being among the “clearly heretical” propositions that must be defeated.

He even went so far as to refer to those prelates who support such things as “these heretical bishops.”

In light of this, Bishop Schneider states:

Pope Francis ought necessarily to intervene and demand that the participants in the “synodal path” formally profess those truths and universal sacramental practices of the Church, which they are calling into question…

The Pope cannot passively stand by or be silent as he watches the “wolves” devour the flock or the “arsonists” set fire to the house…

Were the Pope not to correct the heretical decisions of the “synodal path,” he would thereby consent to them by his silence.

Bishop Schneider went on to cite the Arian crisis as a notable precedent for the divisions that the “synodal path” portends. At that time, he writes:

The criteria and guarantee for being truly Catholic was the communion with the Apostolic See in Rome and with the unchanging and constant doctrinal Tradition.

On February 7, I reached out to Bishop Schneider, who has been gracious enough to respond to my queries in the past, for comment. Specifically, I invited him to comment on the bewildering fact that he is calling on Francis to interrupt an “attempt to give official approval to truly heretical doctrines” that he has already approved via the document Amoris Laetitia.

I also reminded him of the fact that Francis ordered the Buenos Aires Bishops’ guidelines allowing for “the admittance to Holy Communion of people living in adultery” published in the Acta Apostolicae Sedis (AAS), along with his own letter stating “there are no other interpretations” of Amoris Laetitia.

As of this writing, Bishop Schneider, who is among the best of the “full communion” lot, has not responded. [NOTE: I hope to be proven wrong, but it seems that Bishop Schneider, like Cardinal Burke, may have narrowed his media contacts down to a handful of low-t “traditional,” fence sitting, closet neo-con cheerleaders who are willing to parrot whatever he happens to state unchallenged.]

In any case, we are left with more questions than answers concerning exactly what Bishop Schneider has in mind and what he hopes to accomplish via his recent statement. So, let’s consider a few…

Is it possible that he genuinely does not see the absurdity of his request for Francis’ intervention in the matter?

This was my first thought. In hindsight, however, it seems highly unlikely that Bishop Schneider could be so entirely disconnected from reality.

This leaves us with but one other option, at least insofar as I can imagine; namely, the possibility that he is taking the opportunity – stealthily and by way of implication alone – to accuse Francis of his own crimes. While this theory is perhaps more likely than the alternative, it too is rife with difficulty.

Readers may recall that Bishop Schneider went on record in May 2019 as saying that the Open Letter accusing Francis of heresy in light of Amoris Laetitia “went too far.”

Has he since come to the undeniable realization that Francis, by lending his “approval to truly heretical doctrines” vis-à-vis Amoris Laetitia has properly revealed himself to be “heretical”?

In asking Francis to demand that the German bishops formally profess those truths and universal sacramental practices of the Church, is he subtly urging Francis to reconsider answering the questions that are posed in the Dubia?

Is he suggesting that Francis’ silence in the face of the Dubia may rightly be considered his “official approval of truly heretical doctrines, with their correspondent sacramental and pastoral practices”?

Bishop Schneider went on to say in his statement that faithful priests and bishops “will not be able to maintain communion with those German bishops who advocate heretical teachings” such as those under discussion.

Is he hinting that remaining in communion with Francis, the putative Bishop of Rome – that is, treating him as if he were a true pope – is fast becoming untenable for those who wish nothing more than the “guarantee of being truly Catholic”?

Like I said, at this point we’re left with more questions than answers. Unfortunately, the further we delve into his statement, the worse things look for Bishop Schneider.

The consequences of Francis’ failure to “intervene with an unambiguous profession of the Catholic Faith and the perennial sacramental practice of the Church,” according to Bishop Schneider, would be such that “the Catholic Church would in appearance and practice be similar to the Anglican Communion or to a Protestant Free Church.”

Here, we have a genuine case of cognitive dissonance.

You see, if a reigning pope were to consent to “truly heretical doctrines, with their correspondent sacramental and pastoral practices” such as those mentioned in Bishop Schneider’s statement, it could no longer be said that the “Apostolic See in Rome” has preserved “the unchanging and constant doctrinal Tradition.”

In this case, we would be faced with far more than mere appearances.

In other words, the gates of Hell – understood as “the death-dealing tongues of heretics” according to the Second Council of Constantinople – will have prevailed.

As we have noted, however, this is no longer a matter of speculation as Francis has already officially approved – not only by silence, but by direct decree – these very same, truly heretical, doctrines!

So, have the gates of Hell prevailed? Certainly not!

The only possible answers to this conundrum are plain: The institution presently operating out of Rome under the direction of Jorge Bergoglio cannot possibly be the Holy Catholic Church, and this Francis person is most certainly not a true pope.

There are no other choices, folks.

In conclusion, even if Bishop Schneider’s statement is an effort to stealthily accuse Francis of being a heretic – the best case scenario insofar as his own Catholic credibility is concerned – he would emerge from this exercise far more the coward than the “hero.”

aka Modernist war

Share this post on:facebooktwittergoogle_plusreddit
Follow us on:facebooktwittergoogle_plusvimeo

Latest Comments

  1. mothermostforgiving February 18, 2020
  2. Ratio February 18, 2020
  3. Lynda February 18, 2020
  4. PNF February 18, 2020
  5. Evangeline February 18, 2020
  6. Clare Polansky February 18, 2020
  7. Rushintuit February 18, 2020
  8. Joseph a Christian February 18, 2020
  9. 2Vermont February 18, 2020
  10. Clare Polansky February 18, 2020
  11. Joseph a Christian February 18, 2020
  12. Joseph a Christian February 18, 2020
  13. 2Vermont February 19, 2020
  14. my2cents February 19, 2020
  15. Melanie February 19, 2020
  16. my2cents February 19, 2020
  17. Melanie February 19, 2020
  18. my2cents February 19, 2020
  19. Rushintuit February 19, 2020
  20. Tom A February 19, 2020
  21. Anastagi February 19, 2020
  22. Anastagi February 19, 2020
  23. my2cents February 19, 2020
  24. Lynda February 19, 2020
  25. St Cyprian February 19, 2020
  26. John Madison February 19, 2020
  27. Rushintuit February 19, 2020
  28. Melanie February 19, 2020
  29. Lynda February 19, 2020
  30. Anastagi February 19, 2020
  31. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 19, 2020
  32. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 19, 2020
  33. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 19, 2020
  34. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 19, 2020
  35. my2cents February 19, 2020
  36. Evangeline February 19, 2020
  37. Melanie February 19, 2020
  38. Rushintuit February 19, 2020
  39. Melanie February 19, 2020
  40. JTLiuzza February 19, 2020
  41. Rushintuit February 19, 2020
  42. Joseph a Christian February 19, 2020
  43. mothermostforgiving February 19, 2020
  44. St Cyprian February 19, 2020
  45. Tom A February 20, 2020
  46. Tom A February 20, 2020
  47. my2cents February 20, 2020
  48. In caritas February 20, 2020
  49. In caritas February 20, 2020
  50. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 20, 2020
  51. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 20, 2020
  52. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 20, 2020
  53. In caritas February 20, 2020
  54. In caritas February 20, 2020
  55. ock February 20, 2020
  56. St Cyprian February 20, 2020
  57. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 20, 2020
  58. St Cyprian February 20, 2020
  59. In caritas February 21, 2020
  60. St Cyprian February 21, 2020
  61. crawler February 21, 2020
  62. In caritas February 21, 2020
  63. St Cyprian February 21, 2020
  64. St Cyprian February 21, 2020
  65. St Cyprian February 21, 2020
  66. In caritas February 21, 2020
  67. St Cyprian February 21, 2020
  68. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 21, 2020
  69. St Cyprian February 21, 2020
  70. my2cents February 21, 2020
  71. Lynda February 21, 2020
  72. Melanie February 21, 2020
  73. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 21, 2020
  74. A Simple Man February 22, 2020
  75. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 22, 2020
  76. 2Vermont February 22, 2020
  77. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 22, 2020
  78. 2Vermont February 22, 2020
  79. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 22, 2020
  80. 2Vermont February 22, 2020
  81. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 22, 2020
  82. 2Vermont February 22, 2020
  83. Anastasia February 22, 2020
  84. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 22, 2020
  85. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 22, 2020
  86. 2Vermont February 22, 2020
  87. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 22, 2020
  88. 2Vermont February 22, 2020
  89. mpoulin February 22, 2020
  90. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 22, 2020
  91. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 22, 2020
  92. 2Vermont February 22, 2020
  93. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 22, 2020
  94. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 22, 2020
  95. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 22, 2020
  96. Melanie February 22, 2020
  97. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 22, 2020
  98. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 22, 2020
  99. 2Vermont February 22, 2020
  100. 2Vermont February 22, 2020
  101. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 22, 2020
  102. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 22, 2020
  103. mpoulin February 22, 2020
  104. Lynda February 22, 2020
  105. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 22, 2020
  106. Lynda February 22, 2020
  107. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 22, 2020
  108. mothermostforgiving February 24, 2020
  109. In caritas February 25, 2020
  110. In caritas February 25, 2020
  111. Melanie February 25, 2020
  112. Johnbilbee February 25, 2020
  113. Johnbilbee February 25, 2020
  114. St Cyprian February 25, 2020
  115. Johnbilbee February 26, 2020
  116. Johnbilbee February 26, 2020
  117. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 26, 2020
  118. In caritas February 26, 2020
  119. In caritas February 26, 2020
  120. Johnbilbee February 26, 2020
  121. A Simple Man February 26, 2020
  122. Johnbilbee February 26, 2020
  123. Johnbilbee February 26, 2020
  124. Johnbilbee February 26, 2020
  125. Johnbilbee February 26, 2020
  126. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 26, 2020
  127. Tom A February 26, 2020
  128. In caritas February 26, 2020
  129. In caritas February 26, 2020
  130. A Simple Man February 26, 2020
  131. my2cents February 26, 2020
  132. Tom A February 26, 2020
  133. In caritas February 26, 2020
  134. Lynda February 26, 2020
  135. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 26, 2020
  136. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 26, 2020
  137. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 26, 2020
  138. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 26, 2020
  139. Lynda February 26, 2020
  140. my2cents February 26, 2020
  141. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 26, 2020
  142. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 26, 2020
  143. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 26, 2020
  144. my2cents February 26, 2020
  145. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 26, 2020
  146. In caritas February 27, 2020
  147. In caritas February 27, 2020
  148. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 27, 2020
  149. In caritas February 27, 2020
  150. Lynda February 27, 2020
  151. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 27, 2020
  152. NobisQuoquePeccatoribus February 27, 2020
  153. In caritas February 28, 2020
  154. james_o March 18, 2020