Abdication fascination

PapalcopterAs mentioned in the previous post, it appears rather obvious that in the publication of Summorum Pontificum and his defense of the same, Pope Benedict XVI violated his own convictions, and deeply held ones at that, on any number of important points.

In his book, The Spirit of the Liturgy, written after nineteen years of service in Rome as Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, just five years prior to his elevation to the papacy and seven years before Summorum Pontificum, Cardinal Ratzinger made no bones about his view of the Novus Ordo Missae.

Did he believe its creation to be an example of liturgical “growth and progress” properly speaking? No.

Did he view the new Mass as a rupture relative to the venerable liturgical tradition that preceded it? Of course.

Did he imagine the Novus Ordo and the traditional Mass to be equals? Certainly not.

And yet, relative to the promotion of the norms established in Summorum Pontificum, he put pen to paper to make the opposite case.

What does this say about his motives?

Nothing.  At the end of the day, this isn’t our concern. I’m perfectly willing to assume that Pope Benedict shielded the faithful from the scandalizing truth such as he understood it because he believed, rightly or wrongly, that this would best serve the Church at that moment. The Lord will judge.

What this episode in the Benedictine papacy does tell us, however, is that he was willing, in the course of conducting the affairs of the Church, to violate his own convictions; to put forth even in writing that which he arguably understood to be false in order to achieve a particular end.

Fast forward to February 10, 2013:

Pope Benedict XVI declared before the College of Cardinals his incapacity for carrying out the Petrine ministry and his intention to renounce the same, citing a lack of strength of mind and body as the reason.

Can anyone be blamed for wondering if the Holy Father, in announcing his abdication, once again deliberately skirted around a deeper, and potentially scandalizing, truth as a means to an end?

So, what exactly do we know?

Benedict declared himself incapable, both mentally and physically, to carry on.

Several days later, he delivered, without notes, a lengthy address to the parish priests and other clergy of Rome. Not only was his mental acuity unquestioned; it was hailed.

His last public appearance took place on April 27, 2014 at the canonizations. Though he walked with a cane, he was far from showing signs of a physical “incapacity” such that he would be, even now, unable to “adequately fulfill the ministry” of the pope.

Benedict further suggested in his declaration that he was making way for someone better able, both mentally and physically, to address “questions of deep relevance for the life of faith, in order to govern the barque of Saint Peter and proclaim the Gospel.”

Following his departure, the Conclave elected, and in very short order, Jorge Bergoglio, a 76 year old man with one lung whose public discourse strongly suggests even to his most devoted cheerleaders that he is far duller of intellect than his predecessor.

To be clear, I certainly don’t claim to know the whole story, but one thing I’m fairly certain about is this, the declaration of February 10, 2013 isn’t it.

Share this post on:facebooktwittergoogle_plusreddit
Follow us on:facebooktwittergoogle_plusvimeo

Latest Comments

  1. Dumb_ox June 18, 2014
    • GreatPretender51 June 18, 2014
  2. my2cents June 18, 2014
  3. John Madison June 18, 2014
    • salvemur June 18, 2014
      • salvemur June 18, 2014
  4. A Catholic Thinker June 18, 2014
  5. Michael Leon June 18, 2014
    • Michael Leon June 18, 2014
      • salvemur June 18, 2014
  6. Indignus famulus June 18, 2014
    • A Catholic Thinker June 19, 2014
      • Indignus famulus June 20, 2014
        • A Catholic Thinker June 20, 2014
          • Indignus famulus June 21, 2014
  7. rich June 19, 2014
    • salvemur June 19, 2014
      • salvemur June 19, 2014
        • rich June 19, 2014
          • salvemur June 19, 2014
          • salvemur June 19, 2014
          • Edu June 19, 2014
    • Matthew June 19, 2014
      • rich June 19, 2014
      • A Catholic Thinker June 19, 2014
        • rich June 20, 2014
      • A Catholic Thinker June 20, 2014
  8. salvemur June 19, 2014
  9. salvemur June 19, 2014
  10. bigfred June 19, 2014
    • bigfred June 19, 2014
      • cdon June 19, 2014
        • bigfred June 19, 2014
        • bigfred June 20, 2014
  11. Michael Leon June 19, 2014
    • Indignus famulus June 21, 2014
  12. salvemur June 19, 2014
  13. JamesTheLesser June 19, 2014
    • GreatPretender51 June 19, 2014
      • JamesTheLesser June 19, 2014
        • Indignus famulus June 19, 2014
          • JamesTheLesser June 20, 2014
      • A Catholic Thinker June 19, 2014
    • A Catholic Thinker June 19, 2014
      • JamesTheLesser June 20, 2014
        • A Catholic Thinker June 20, 2014
  14. Indignus famulus June 19, 2014
  15. Indignus famulus June 19, 2014
  16. Chris Ferrara June 19, 2014
    • Edu June 19, 2014
  17. Chris Ferrara June 19, 2014
    • bigfred June 19, 2014
      • A Catholic Thinker June 19, 2014
        • Indignus famulus June 20, 2014
  18. A Catholic Thinker June 19, 2014
  19. Siobhan June 19, 2014
    • Indignus famulus June 19, 2014
      • Indignus famulus June 20, 2014
          • Indignus famulus June 20, 2014
          • Edu June 20, 2014
  20. bigfred June 19, 2014
    • Indignus famulus June 19, 2014
      • bigfred June 19, 2014
      • A Catholic Thinker June 19, 2014
        • bigfred June 19, 2014
          • Indignus famulus June 20, 2014
  21. bigfred June 19, 2014
    • salvemur June 19, 2014
      • bigfred June 19, 2014
        • bigfred June 20, 2014
        • salvemur June 20, 2014
          • salvemur June 20, 2014
  22. salvemur June 20, 2014
  23. Indignus famulus June 20, 2014
    • JamesTheLesser June 20, 2014
      • Edu June 20, 2014
        • JamesTheLesser June 20, 2014
          • JamesTheLesser June 20, 2014
      • de Maria numquam satis June 20, 2014
        • JamesTheLesser June 20, 2014
  24. Ontarienne69 June 20, 2014
    • Indignus famulus June 20, 2014
  25. Indignus famulus June 20, 2014
    • de Maria numquam satis June 20, 2014
  26. Indignus famulus June 20, 2014
    • de Maria numquam satis June 20, 2014
  27. Indignus famulus June 20, 2014
    • JamesTheLesser June 20, 2014
      • Indignus famulus June 21, 2014
  28. John314 June 20, 2014
  29. Ontarienne69 June 20, 2014
    • bigfred June 21, 2014
  30. salvemur June 20, 2014
    • de Maria numquam satis June 21, 2014
      • salvemur June 21, 2014
        • Indignus famulus June 21, 2014
          • de Maria numquam satis June 21, 2014
          • salvemur June 21, 2014
          • Matthew June 21, 2014
  31. Indignus famulus June 21, 2014
    • Indignus famulus June 21, 2014
  32. Indignus famulus June 21, 2014
  33. de Maria numquam satis June 21, 2014
    • Indignus famulus June 21, 2014
      • A Catholic Thinker June 22, 2014
  34. de Maria numquam satis June 21, 2014
  35. de Maria numquam satis June 21, 2014
    • Indignus famulus June 21, 2014
  36. bigfred June 21, 2014
    • Indignus famulus June 21, 2014
      • bigfred June 22, 2014
  37. salvemur June 21, 2014
  38. Indignus famulus June 22, 2014
    • salvemur June 22, 2014
  39. AnnaMarie June 22, 2014
  40. Indignus famulus June 22, 2014
    • de Maria numquam satis June 22, 2014
      • Indignus famulus June 23, 2014
        • Indignus famulus June 23, 2014
      • bigfred June 23, 2014
    • A Catholic Thinker June 22, 2014
      • Indignus famulus June 23, 2014
  41. A Catholic Thinker June 22, 2014
  42. A Catholic Thinker June 22, 2014
    • Indignus famulus June 23, 2014
      • Indignus famulus June 23, 2014
    • bigfred June 23, 2014
  43. bigfred June 23, 2014
    • bigfred June 23, 2014
    • Indignus famulus June 23, 2014
      • Indignus famulus June 23, 2014
      • bigfred June 23, 2014
        • Indignus famulus June 23, 2014
  44. bigfred June 23, 2014
    • de Maria numquam satis June 23, 2014
      • bigfred June 23, 2014
  45. bigfred June 23, 2014
  46. Indignus famulus June 23, 2014
    • bigfred June 23, 2014
      • Indignus famulus June 23, 2014
        • bigfred June 23, 2014
  47. Indignus famulus June 23, 2014

Leave a Reply