Robert Siscoe Archive
By: Fr. Paul Kramer It is claimed by
In their recent article, The True Meaning of Bellarmine’s Ipso Facto Loss of Papacy, Robert Siscoe and John Salza (S&S for short moving forward) attempted to prove that, according to the Doctor of the Church, in order for a heretical Pope to be deposed, an antecedent judgment of …
By: Robert Siscoe and John Salza The True Meaning of Bellarmine’s Ipso Facto Loss of Office Theory for a Heretical Pope In light of the ongoing crisis in the Church and papacy, many Catholics are questioning whether the man in charge – Pope Francis …
Is the pope Catholic? As any number of commentators have acknowledged in light of the antics of Jorge Bergoglio (stage name, Francis), this is no longer a rhetorical, much less an amusing, question. As I write, more and more sincere Catholics are finding …
By: Robert Siscoe As Louie mentioned, our replies are getting a bit longer, but I would encourage those interested in this topic to stay with us as we are now getting into important material. Regarding Canon 194, Louie wrote: “According to Can. 194, …
By: Robert Siscoe I want to begin by thanking my friend Louie for his reply and for continuing this important discussion. I had originally intended to discuss a different issue in this second installment, but I believe it will be more helpful if …
As I wrote last week, my statements concerning Francis, the dubia, and what I consider to be the judgment of formal heresy that he has pronounced against himself, has been met with a number of objections; not just from the usual suspects, but …
Several months ago, John Salza and Robert Siscoe were kind enough to provide me with a preview taken from their new book, True or False Pope? Refuting Sedevacantism and Other Modern Errors. (NB: This book provides an outstanding treatment of numerous “modern errors,” …