Papal Primacy and the Heresy of Conciliarlism
By: Fr. Paul Kramer It is claimed by
Robert Siscoe Archive
Siscoe and Salza’s Smoking Gun: Is there fire?
In their recent article, The True Meaning of Bellarmine’s Ipso Facto Loss of Papacy, Robert Siscoe and John Salza (S&S for short moving forward) attempted to prove that, according to the Doctor of the Church, in order for a heretical Pope to be deposed, an antecedent judgment of …
The True Meaning of Bellarmine’s Ipso Facto Loss of Papacy
By: Robert Siscoe and John Salza The True Meaning of Bellarmine’s Ipso Facto Loss of Office Theory for a Heretical Pope In light of the ongoing crisis in the Church and papacy, many Catholics are questioning whether the man in charge – Pope Francis …
Can the Roman Pontiff be judged?
Is the pope Catholic? As any number of commentators have acknowledged in light of the antics of Jorge Bergoglio (stage name, Francis), this is no longer a rhetorical, much less an amusing, question. As I write, more and more sincere Catholics are finding …
Point / Counterpoint 3: Siscoe
By: Robert Siscoe As Louie mentioned, our replies are getting a bit longer, but I would encourage those interested in this topic to stay with us as we are now getting into important material. Regarding Canon 194, Louie wrote: “According to Can. 194, …
Point / Counterpoint 2: Robert Siscoe
By: Robert Siscoe I want to begin by thanking my friend Louie for his reply and for continuing this important discussion. I had originally intended to discuss a different issue in this second installment, but I believe it will be more helpful if …
ANNOUNCEMENT: Dubiagate – Point / Counterpoint
As I wrote last week, my statements concerning Francis, the dubia, and what I consider to be the judgment of formal heresy that he has pronounced against himself, has been met with a number of objections; not just from the usual suspects, but …
INTERVIEW: Salza & Siscoe unmask Sedevacantism
Several months ago, John Salza and Robert Siscoe were kind enough to provide me with a preview taken from their new book, True or False Pope? Refuting Sedevacantism and Other Modern Errors. (NB: This book provides an outstanding treatment of numerous “modern errors,” …